Mattress Reviews

Praise for Initial Support

“Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) - 1002 (A very well-made mattress)”

• The Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy
• Purchased from Sleepy's (New York, NY)

Posted by Michael M from San Francisco, CA on February 5, 2010

Overall, we have been very pleased with this mattress from the very beginning, although it began to show some wear after about 6-7 years. When we first got the mattress, it was absolutely dreamlike to sleep on -- the pillowtop was perfectly plush, but with a firm underlying support. We … →

“Chattam & Wells Chateau Double Pillow Top - 1723 (Two Canyons)”

• The Chateau Double Pillow Top model from the Chattam & Wells line by Spring Air
• Purchased from Sleepy's (Selden, NY)

Posted by Scott G from Medford, NY on December 28, 2011

Shame On The Makers Of This Product. Don't Say Your The Best When Your Not. The Mattress Has Two Large Depressions Were My Wife And I Sleep. Sleepy's Is The Seller And They Sent A Rep Out And He Denied The Calim For A Stain. I Guess If You Put … →

“Saatva - 1858 (So glad we bought this mattress!)”

• The Saatva brand

Posted by Corrinne D on April 26, 2012

After many months of searching and deliberating, we decided to order a Saatva Luxury Firm Cal King Mattress. Every part of the purchase and delivery went so smoothly, it amazed us. Ed Brians was our customer service contact. He went above and beyond our expectations in answering questions and processing … →

“Serta iComfort Insight - 2197 (Holy saggy batman)”

• The Insight model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta

Posted by Debra V from Fond Du Lac, WI on October 29, 2012

We took time and chose our set carefully for the right comfort level and this mattress started out quite firm but within weeks it lost its ability to return to shape, we now have a visible big high spot in the middle of the bed and sink down 6 inches … →

“Stearns & Foster Luxury - 1824 (Need Back Support - Bought Lux Estate Cathryn (Kathryn) Luxury Firm)”

• The Stearns & Foster Luxury line by Stearns & Foster
• Purchased from Mattress Firm

Posted by Tula B from Minneapolis, MN on March 27, 2012

Originally purchased a Simmons Oceanside pillowtop. It was too soft and we sank right into it over night. It felt like sleeping in a trough because there was so much cushioning foam and the springs were 15.5 gauge. We exchanged it for this S&F and it is perfect so far. … →

“Natural Response - 1103 (King Koil Natural Response Diva Mattress - Horrible)”

• The Natural Response line by King Koil

Posted by Finkel E from Ridgewood, NJ on May 19, 2010

I am really shocked at the horrible results of this mattress -- within 2 years to the day, this mattress has developed DEEP BODY IMPRESSIONS, sagging at support points ( hips, back, shoulders). Visually, you'd never notice anything. But after 20 minutes the bed simply gives out, and you sink … →

“Tempur-Pedic CelebrityBed (2008) - 2216 (Only Good for 5 Years)”

• The CelebrityBed model from the TEMPUR Collection line by TEMPUR-Pedic

Posted by Brian S from Austin, TX on November 8, 2012

Paid almost $3500 for mattress, foundation and delivery in May 2005. Already had a 3-bed beam support system with 6 legs. Mattress felt great and provided excellent support for first five years or so. Rotated, not flipped (you can't), mattress every 12 months or so. Started to notice soft spots … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Newfield Cushion Firm - 104525 (Bulges)”

• The Newfield Cushion Firm model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Patrick from Oxnard, CA on January 5, 2017

This bed was excellent in the beginning. It was firm, offered great support, and held true to form. After a little over one year and a pregnancy the bed has gone down hill. Bulges have formed at the foot of the bed. I rotated the bed and now have bulges … →

“Strobel - 1855 (company does not stand behind warrantee)”

• The Strobel brand

Posted by Jeni H from Morgan, UT on April 24, 2012

I have spent the last 11 months trying to get this company to stand behind their warrantee. i have now been told that they will give me a discount. this matress was less than 6 years old and sags two inches. crap product and crap company. don't do it! not … →

“Scandinavian Weightless Sleep System - 1764 (dreaming again!)”

• The Weightless Sleep model by Scandinavian
• Purchased from Sleep Center (Columbus, GA)

Posted by Michelle A from Columbus, GA on February 11, 2012

I have back, knee, andshoulder pain....i toss and turned with my mattress from sams club bought this and im dreaming again i sleep so well...i recommend thee pillows too! LOVE IT! Ive only had it one month so i cant say how durable it will be but a friend bought … →

“Chattam & Wells - 1607 (Over sold and under delivered)”

• The Chattam & Wells line by Spring Air
• Purchased from Sleepy's

Posted by Melanee J from Bear, DE on September 5, 2011

We finally decided to get a top of the line mattress since you spend 1/3 of life on it. Sleepy's salesman really pushed this one as top of the line. We moved away from Sterns & Foster at the recommendation of this salesman. What a mistake, we bought a new … →

“Beautyrest Classic - 1666 (DONT EVER BUY A SIMMOMS MATTRESS!)”

• The Beautyrest Classic line by Beautyrest
• Purchased from Sears

Posted by Tony N from Montgomery, NY on October 17, 2011

We bought our first Simmons Beautyrest Matira Extra Firm King Mattress online from Sears for a great price [or so I thought!] on September 8, 2011. [Order #263718602] It was delivered on September 16, 2011. However, we did try it out first at Sears in Middletown, NY and Sleepy’s in … →

“Simmons BackCare - 1148 (Would not buy it again)”

• The Simmons BackCare line by Simmons
• Purchased from Sears

Posted by Marty C from North Vancouver, BC on September 13, 2010

I bought this mattress approximately 4 years ago...for the first year it was fine...after that, it showed significant wear. Through that time I weighed between 170-190 lbs..so not a very large person, the bed frame was strong and I rotated the mattress as often as I could. Eventually you end … →

“Serta Vera Wang Serene Grace Latex Plush - 1188 (Mattress sinks in center!)”

• The Serene Grace Latex Plush model from the Vera Wang by Serta line by Serta
• Purchased from Metro Mattress

Posted by Catrina T from Lyndonville, NY on October 20, 2010

I went with the latex mattress after extensive research and wanting to get away from inner spring mattress then trying it out in the store. It was great at first, meaning a few months. After that I started to notice the center of the mattress would not spring back and … →

“Sealy - 1227 (Double Slump)”

• The Sealy brand
• Purchased from Sit n Sleep (Santa Clarita, CA)

Posted by Mike R from Castaic, CA on November 27, 2010

Paid $1259.99 for the top part of the mattress set with a 10 year warranty. We had great hopes for the bed but now, the back sleeper and has had to add a pillow under hips. The stomach sleeper is up to 4 pillows to keep from sagging. The middle … →

“Serta Perfect Sleeper (Pre-2019) - 1225 (Customer Service Let-down)”

• The Serta Perfect Sleeper (Pre-2019) line by Serta

Posted by Michael B from San Antonio, TX on November 23, 2010

I bought this mattress is AZ at a military AAFES store. It was a great mattress and slept well for about 6 months. After than the mattress began sagging on both sides. You could feel lumps in the middle 1/3 areas. I called Serta and they requested pictures and the … →

“Aireloom Handcrafted - 1213 (Poor memory foam)”

• The Aireloom Handcrafted line by Aireloom
• Purchased from The Dump (Irving, TX)

Posted by Ron E from Keller, TX on November 12, 2010

We purchased an Aireloom mattress July 07, from a store called "The Dump". We are very unsatisfied with this mattress. It has two large indentions on each side, where my wife and I sleep. The memory foam built into this mattress has completely broken down to the point that when … →

“Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) - 2132 (Waking up with sore backs)”

• The Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta
• Purchased from Sleep Country Canada

Posted by K L from Burnaby, BC on September 30, 2012

This is our 5th bed that we have purchased and we had always heard about Tempurpedic mattresses being the best and most comfortable. The salesman was very educated with the details of mattresses and sold us on the new iComfort offering from Serta mainly because of the reduced smell and … →

“Simmons BeautyRest Exceptionale Joseph Abboud - 1360 (back spasms)”

• The Joseph Abboud model from the Beautyrest Exceptionale line by Beautyrest
• Purchased from Macy's (Silverdale, WA)

Posted by Cathie W from Poulsbo, WA on February 16, 2011

For 5 years, it was great and then began to sag. At 7 years, I awoke with back spasms and could not stand up straight. I sleep in another room now to avoid back pain. Macy's and Simmons do not care. If my husband comes near me (in the bed) … →

“Serta Vera Wang Petals Euro Top - 1187 (WIsh I kept my old bed!)”

• The Petals Euro Top model from the Vera Wang by Serta line by Serta

Posted by Craig T from Murrysville, PA on October 19, 2010

I weigh 190lb, and sleep alone....within 6 months I noticed serious sagging in center of bed where the saleperson pitched about alll of the support and the double springs,blah,blah,blah. Well I will tell you it feels like they forgot to install any springs, there is absolutely no spring back whatsoever....I … →

“Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image - 1229 (Horrible - Do not buy - Especially from Rooms to Go)”

• The Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image line by Carolina Mattress Guild
• Purchased from Rooms To Go

Posted by Sarah F from Tampa, FL on November 28, 2010

My boyfriend and I bought this bed from Rooms to Go. I thought it would be a nice alternative to the Tempurpedic bed which were way too expensive for us. Well I should have listened to my boyfriend and just gotten another spring mattress! This thing is horrible. It was … →

“Spring Air Back Supporter Four Seasons - 2244 (Terrible)”

• The Spring Air Back Supporter line by Spring Air

Posted by Rosalie S from Henderson, KY on November 17, 2012

DO NOT PURCHASE THIS MATTRESS! After 6 months the mattress begins to sag and Spring Air gives you the run arounds over the warranty of the mattress. There is a 2 inch sag and my husband and I have to put pillows between us to keep from rolling on top … →

“Simmons BeautyRest NxG 250 - 2482 (Among the springs in the Springs)”

• The NxG 250 model from the Beautyrest NxG line by Beautyrest
• Purchased from Macy's (Colorado Springs, CO)

Posted by David B from Colorado Springs, CO on February 18, 2013

We originally purchased the BeautyRest Angelique Visco Cushion Firm King from Macy's in 2008. It started started sinking right away. Macy's sent out the guy and he reported the almost 2 inch valley. Macy's allowed us to upgrade to the NXG250 Luxury Firm mattress ($2260) if we paid the $150 … →

“Christeli - 1990 (Best investment!)”

• The Christeli brand

Posted by Alexis T from Port Washington, NY on July 25, 2012

Probably the best investment I have made this year. I had a traditional boxspring and woke up every morning sore and stiff. One night in the luxepedic and my back felt a million times better!! Fast delivery! Extremely comfortable and the memory foam does not get hot at all. I've … →

“Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) - 2045 (Mattress has lost its consistent density. Causes back ache every night/day)”

• The Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta
• Purchased from Mattress Warehouse / Sleep Happens

Posted by Lyndal C from Bear, DE on August 26, 2012

this mattress is very expensive, Im wondering what the difference is with the no name brands in BJ's etc. After about 2 mths the foam has lost its hardness and has become very inconsistent with the density of the layers of foam. This makes my husband and my back ache. … →

“Sealy - 2077 (Guarntee same as warranty)”

• The Sealy brand
• Purchased from Better Bedding (Ansonia, CT)

Posted by Russell S from Oxford, CT on September 5, 2012

Sealy's raves best support, but after mattress is used (only 4 years old) at a cost of $ 2800.00 for the set. They didn't want to hear about being uncomfortable in their product, that it will only get softer in time. Great to hear Claims their warranty is the same … →

“Sleeptronic Royal Rest - 2113 (Famsa)”

• The Sleeptronic Royal Rest line by Sleeptronic
• Purchased from Famsa (Houston, TX)

Posted by Anthony R from Pasadena, TX on September 19, 2012

I still remembered the woman selling us this bed, OOoo is the best of the best, I highly recomend you getting this mattress is the best, yea the best of the nightmares after a few months. →

“Serta iComfort Prodigy Plush - 2158 (Bliss)”

• The Prodigy Plush model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta
• Purchased from Metro Mattress

Posted by David F from Ithaca, NY on October 15, 2012

They say that the people that write reviews are those that either love or hate the product. Well, we are the ones that love it. I weigh 185 and my girlfriend is about 115. We have only had it for two months but we both rave about it. Although it … →

“Summerhill & Bischop - 2536 (oaky at first)”

• The Summerhill & Bischop line by Ortho

Posted by Jaime H from Spotsylvania, VA on March 10, 2013

We needed a new mattress and it was good for the first 4 years. It began to deteriorate after the 4th year. If you have the choice do not buy this mattress. It will not keep up with the warranty of time given. If you need to buy it please … →

“Serta Trump Home - 2555 (Gone bad after 2 years)”

• The Serta Trump Home line by Serta

Posted by Luz S from Crestview, FL on March 13, 2013

We have had this mattress for 24 months. We have severe body impressions that are now causing us of have restless nights and back pain in the morning. Serta has denied our claim since the body impressions aren't greater than 1 3/4" in depth. My husband is in the military … →

“Innomax Supple-Pedic - 1708 (deceiving)”

• The Innomax Supple-Pedic line by InnoMax

Posted by Jen H from Roy, UT on December 9, 2011

great in the beginning. even talked two friends into buying one. best sleep i ever had. three years later it begain sagging. seven years later the company barely acknowledges my e-mail or phone calls. I am yest to see a refund or replacement. not worth the $3,000 i paid for … →

“Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image Essential Pillowtop - 2644 (No springs = Sleeping in a crevice)”

• The Essential Pillowtop model from the Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image line by Carolina Mattress Guild
• Purchased from Rooms To Go (Schertz, TX)

Posted by Jessica M from San Antonio, TX on April 25, 2013

My husband and I agreed on this bed because he prefers a firmer bed and this one did not seem too hard for me. The pillow top at the time of purchase was not too soft and because of the lack of springs, we hoped we would not experience the … →

“Kluft - 2646 (Most costly mistake ever)”

• The Kluft brand

Posted by Roberta P from Rochester, MI on April 29, 2013

When I tried the bed in the store I had never felt anything so comfortable. From the very first night and ever night I had it, I slept better than I ever have. Then I found some small holes in the top and side,,,no big deal I just thought they … →

“Serta iComfort Genius - 2691 (Sags, and NO Support after 4 months)”

• The Genius model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta

Posted by Mike D from New Braunfels, TX on May 29, 2013

I purchased a Serta, iComfort Genius, King Mattress and foundation on November 20, 2012. After four months the foam is soft, saggy and offers no support. Mattress Firm sells this bed as a firm bed which it was for a few months. I filed and paid $25.00 for an inspection,a … →

“miForma Relieve 12" - 2700 (I EXPECTED MORE FROM THIS MATTRESS..)”

• The Relieve 12" model by miForma
• Purchased from Back To Bed (Chicago, IL)

Posted by S D from Chicago, IL on June 3, 2013

Thought I'd try a memory foam bed over previous Simmons innerspring which lasted a good 8 years before I had to put it out to pasture. Mi Forma was more in my price point - though obviously not worth it considering I needed to replace it due to horrible low … →

“Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) - 2708 (From GREAT to HORRIBLE )”

• The Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta
• Purchased from Mattress Firm (Round Rock, TX)

Posted by Tim D from Austin, TX on June 9, 2013

We bought the new Revolution Icomfort by Serta from Mattress Firm January 2012 on the recommendation of the salesman (Joseph Sabino). He told us that after the break-in period that we would find the mattress would contour to our body and give us the support we're looking for. In the … →

“Primo - 2792 (WAS a wonderful mattress.)”

• The Primo brand

Posted by Anne S from New Hartford, NY on July 24, 2013

My hubby likes very soft mattresses and I like firm. This mattress (when we first got it) was PERFECT. It gave him the feeling of plush and me the feeling of support. 18 months later I was at Joe Tahan's Furniture asking about warranty information because even my hubby now … →

“ComforPedic Loft - 2839 (The most horrible overprice bed ever!)”

• The ComforPedic line by Simmons

Posted by Jo A from Lancaster, PA on August 29, 2013

We ended up buying this $1,800 (mind you on sale) bed because we were concerned for the heating issues we heard about tempurpedic. The claims that this bed would provide quick response on movement and keep you cool were our selling points. Unfortunately after owning this piece of crap for … →

“Sealy Posture Premier Luxury Pillowtop - 2873 (Disappointed)”

• The Luxury Pillowtop model from the Sealy Posture Premier line by Sealy

Posted by Hugh P from Port Sydney, ON on September 20, 2013

We purchased this mattress with the expectation that it would last -- paid top dollar, and from a "respected" manufacturer. The mattress was great for the first year or so then it went down hill. The manufactures method of measuring sag is flawed and is only intended to provide them … →

“Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Classic Sanderling Luxury Firm Pillowtop - 2931 (Buyer Beware)”

• The Sanderling Luxury Firm Pillowtop model from the Beautyrest Recharge line by Beautyrest

Posted by Meredith M from West Chester, PA on October 24, 2013

I was in love with this bed until, after 4 weeks, I noticed a body indentation started to form. My initial reaction was - I'm imagining this, it can't be happening! Well not only was it happening, but it has grown worse! My previous bed was a pillowtop and I … →

“Serta Trump iSeries Corbin Plush - 2962 (It may be cooler than 100% memory foam, but it's not cool)”

• The Corbin Plush model from the Serta iSeries (Pre-2021) line by Serta

Posted by Nancy T from Denver, CO on November 12, 2013

I was looking for a bed with pressure relief and that slept "cool". This "hybrid" seemed like the perfect solution since I understand that memory foam sleeps hot, even though "they" have been trying to remedy that complaint. Since I haven't slept on a 100% memory foam mattress, I can't … →

“ComforPedic Loft - 3045 (Be careful before purchasing a foam mattress)”

• The ComforPedic line by Simmons

Posted by Christopher J from Greenwood, MO on January 10, 2014

When we first tried our mattress in the store it was incredible. For the first six months it was great. About that time we noticed something changing and tried rotating the bed 180 degrees. That worked for about six more months. We tried rotating it back, but the support was … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Mountain Vale Firm - 3053 (Awful)”

• The Mountain Vale Firm model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy
• Purchased from Havertys (Fayetteville, GA)

Posted by Matthew W from Tyrone, GA on January 13, 2014

Haverty's has already replaced it twice (we're on our third mattress) and they're about to replace it again. Thankfully this model has been discontinued at Haverty's. →

“Sealy Posturepedic Yale - 18562 (Excellent bed)”

• The Yale model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Randall from Bothell, WA on August 6, 2015

Firm and supportive yet the plush top is a soft layer and the edge support is an added bonus, it does not crush or sag. I get a great nights sleep with this bed. →

“Kingsdown - 3161 (Warranty not backed by company and not all exceptions listed)”

• The Kingsdown brand
• Purchased from Levin's of Virginia

Posted by Susan P from Chesapeake, VA on March 16, 2014

Our Warranty was LT ("For as long as Kingsdown product is owned by original purchaser") At the time it was bought it was excellent but it started sagging across the middle. We called Levins Brass Beds where we purchasd it and an independent person was sent by Kingsdown. He measured … →

“Easy Rest Deluxe - 3521 (Great mattress at first, but all goes downhill from there...)”

• The Deluxe model by Easy Rest

Posted by Joe from Markham, ON on May 22, 2014

Had the mattress for about 3 years now. Coming from a spring mattress, the initial feeling was very comfortable and provided very good support. Did have slight gassing (odor) but that went away within a week. After about a year though, the firmness started to deteriorate. My side of the … →

“Serta iSeries (Pre-2021) - 3594 (Just wish there was more information)”

• The Serta iSeries (Pre-2021) line by Serta
• Purchased from Nebraska Furniture Mart (Omaha, NE)

Posted by Stephanie from Omaha, NE on July 7, 2014

My husband and I just bought the iSeries Vantage Plush and had it delivered yesterday. The first night of sleeping in it was GREAT! Both of us slept really well, and neither of us disturbed the other when we got up, which is a very welcome change from our last … →

“PedicSolutions 12" Memory Foam - 3616 (Beyond Disappointed)”

• The 12" Memory Foam model by PedicSolutions
• Purchased from QVC

Posted by Joycee from Crofton, MD on July 17, 2014

I paid over $800 f/this mattress that only lasted 3 1/2 years. Not sure if this is an issue of memory foam or the company, but the memory of your body never goes away and you find yourself sleeping in a hole. My back and hip is hurting constantly. Wish … →

“Serta Perfect Day iSeries Profiles Aim Super Pillow Top - 3620 (true comfort)”

• The Profiles Aim Super Pillow Top model from the Serta iSeries (Pre-2021) line by Serta
• Purchased from Conn's

Posted by Susan from Crawford, TX on July 18, 2014

We bought a tempurpedic first. . And it was defective...The customer service was horrible to say the least. ..I decided to check into other brands and came across the Aim super pillow top..It has a two in one mattress. A cooling foam gel pillow top with dual coils for support. … →

“Origins - 3624 (Broke down in less than 6 months)”

• The Origins line by International Bedding

Posted by Jesse from Scottsdale, AZ on July 20, 2014

Expensive, Huge "Crater" body impressions, Lumps developed, Store didn't want to take it back, Broke down extremely quickly. Appears cheaper materials for an expensive retail cost. Definitely not satisfied. Store gave me a really good price and was helpful when shopping but didn't seem to want to return the mattress. … →

“Jamestown - 3629 (Poorly designed, spring box makes creaking noise )”

• The Jamestown brand

Posted by Peter L from Lyons, NY on July 22, 2014

I bought king size mattress and spring boxes from the Jamestown Mattress Co, couple month later it started making creaking noise. Called the company they replaced the boxes it turned out to be the same story. I looked inside the boxes and the planks are thin, cheap material with cardboard … →

“Beautyrest TruEnergy Becca Plush Firm - 3727 (Comfort and support changed quickly)”

• The Becca Plush Firm model from the Beautyrest TruEnergy line by Beautyrest
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Shirlan H from Romulus, MI on August 5, 2014

Initial comfort and support was good, but after 1 year there is a noticeable difference in support. Often wake up with stiffness in lower back and shoulders. →

“Beautyrest - 3736 (I have only had it a little over 1 year and finding that ...)”

• The Beautyrest brand
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Lauri E from Clinton Township, MI on August 5, 2014

I have only had it a little over 1 year and finding that there are lumps in it. I had reviewed other mattress at the time of purchase and thought I would go with this one because it felt comy in the showroom and was a good price. I've since … →

“TEMPUR-Simplicity Firm - 3810 (Great at first, but rapidly loses firmness)”

• The Simplicity Firm model from the TEMPUR-Simplicity Collection line by TEMPUR-Pedic
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Jerry A from Clinton Township, MI on August 6, 2014

I have another, king size tempur-pedic, also purchased firm. it has become soft over time, but the warranty only kicks in if the mattress develops a 3/4 inch or more sag, and acording to the warranty, there is no help if it just gets soft. This new twin size got … →

“BedInABox Natural Silk Elegance Comfort Adjust Gel - 4347 (Very comfortable, great support yet plush at the same time. )”

• The Natural Silk Elegance Comfort Adjust Gel model by BedInABox

Posted by Jesse from Smithtown, NY on December 15, 2014

I've been sleeping on firm spring beds for many years for the back support, this bed is so comfortable - soft and plush yet super supportive as well. Have had the best sleep in years since we got this bed. Seems very well made, and i feel the price is … →

“Serta iComfort Genius - 4105 (My husband and I are heavy, the middle of the mattress fe...)”

• The Genius model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Robin W from Carleton, MI on September 18, 2014

My husband and I are heavy, the middle of the mattress feels sunk in. I roll towards my husband when sleeping. The mattress does not hold it's form for long in the middle. I wake up with back aches. →

“Saatva Classic 14.5" Luxury Firm - 4078 (Best bed I have ever owned)”

• The Saatva Classic Luxury Firm 14.5" model by Saatva

Posted by Catmom from Ramsey, NJ on September 18, 2014

I had to replace a 17 year old Kingsdown bed that I had to put a memory foam topper on to make it sleep-able, but even that was failing. It never made its 20 year warranty and new ones are $3000+. I found Saatva through online research and ordered a … →

“Serta - 4057 (2 1/2 stars )”

• The Serta brand
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Michelle R from New Baltimore, MI on September 17, 2014

Mattress was extremely comfortable when we first purchased it. Within a few months, mattress began to lose its "magic." Feels much firmer than it did upon initial purchase. CANNOT BE FLIPPED!! If you and your "sleepmate" are different weights, the non-flippability factor becomes an issue over time. No warranty because … →

“Octaspring 5500 - 4023 (Nice bed- no heat)”

• The 5500 model from the Dormeo Octaspring line by Dormeo

Posted by Bill on September 16, 2014

I was on a temper classic for 8 years- tiried of sweating- so seen dormeo's infomercial and took a chance. Love the bed- no sweating - comfortable for my partner and myself. →

“Sealy Posturepedic SpringFree - 122340 (Was Good for Ten Years)”

• The Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Sernja from Raleigh, NC on March 1, 2017

Purchased around 2006 when it first was offered as alternative to spring mattresses. It's 2017 and the foam has soft places that no longer support. SpringFree was a great choice at the time, but it's life span is over. I think this is true for all foam mattresses. Ten years … →

“Restonic - 4255 (Garbage Crap)”

• The Restonic brand
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Krishna S from Detroit, MI on October 23, 2014

This bed was suppose to be an extra firm mattress but it turn out that less then a few months after use, it started to sag. I wish I could get my money back because it is painful to wake up every day in this garbage. I will never buy … →

“Sealy PerfectRest Dunloe - 4284 (Starts Firm Goes Soft)”

• The Dunloe model from the Sealy PerfectRest line by Sealy
• Purchased from Sleep Country Canada

Posted by B from Nanaimo, BC on November 7, 2014

My back is killing me. 11 months in and the firmness has gone. My hip sinks into the bed causing a horrible back ache. I've resorted to sleeping on the floor, and that has helped. →

“Spring Air Back Supporter Latex Hybrid Natalie Ultra Firm - 17024 (Helped my back pain)”

• The Natalie Ultra Firm model from the Spring Air Back Supporter line by Spring Air
• Purchased from Costco

Posted by Mike S from Bend, OR on July 15, 2015

I have back pain, which is more pronounced when lying on my side. I thought my other mattress was fine as it didn't appear to be worn or sagging. However, this mattress provides firm support without being too hard. I would buy it again. →

“Saatva Classic 11.5" Firm - 14970 (Best mattress ever.)”

• The Saatva Classic Firm 11.5" model by Saatva

Posted by Ramon from Brandon, FL on June 14, 2015

The best mattress i bought in my life, King Size Firm Delivery in June 9, 2015 and in a week no more back pain Just try it and you wiil sleep overall the clouds. Thanks you SAATVA. →

“Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Classic Bromont Firm - 8735 (Sags in 6 months)”

• The Bromont Firm model from the Beautyrest Recharge line by Beautyrest

Posted by Lori from Rotonda West, FL on February 27, 2015

Ready to approach Sears to resolve this. Absolutely not tolerable to have a sag within 6 months. Hip and Back pain upon waking every morning →

“Octaspring Serenite LuxeBED Plush / Firm - 4898 (Impressed with Dormeo Octaspring LuxeBED)”

• The Serenite LuxeBED Plush / Firm model from the Dormeo Octaspring line by Dormeo

Posted by Patrick from Galena, OH on December 29, 2014

My wife and I owned this mattress for four months and so far we are very pleased with it. She has back issues and prefers a firm mattress while I typically prefer something softer. We found this mattress to be much more comfortable than most inner spring mattresses and we … →

“Serta Perfect Day Reawaken Euro Top - 5642 (No durability)”

• The Reawaken Euro Top model from the Serta Perfect Day line by Serta

Posted by SJ from Victoria, BC on January 7, 2015

Have had this bed for 7 years. Getting a new bed tomorrow, couldn't stand sleeping in the "bed taco" anymore. This thing has such a bad sag and though it is still within the ten year warranty, I just want it gone. I can't even sleep on my side because … →

“Sealy 7000 Plush - 15281 (Back problems now)”

• The 7000 Plush model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy
• Purchased from Slumberland (Madison, WI)

Posted by Kate from Sun Prairie, WI on June 18, 2015

I have had significant low back pain since owning this mattress. Initially is was fine but after a period of time, it was all downhill. I have a great night of sleep elsewhere and dont wake up stiff. With this bed I do. Im a side sleeper and it seems … →

“Stearns & Foster Signature - 8714 (Great Mattress, Great Store)”

• The Stearns & Foster Signature line by Stearns & Foster
• Purchased from Mattress King

Posted by Glenn from Muskogee, OK on February 26, 2015

Earl was very helpful in the store and not at all pushy. He is knowledgeable and made the shopping and buying experience great. I highly recommend Mattress King in Muskogee and love this Stearns and Foster Mattress! →

“GhostBed Classic - 364985 (Good Mattress Overall)”

• The GhostBed Classic model by GhostBed

Posted by Gary from Winter Haven, FL on March 28, 2019

Initial comfort is great. Relieved a lot of back and foot pain. About 2 years in now and it is starting to feel a bit like my old mattress. →

“Englander - 16355 (Owned mine since 2010)”

• The Englander brand

Posted by Jim from Wasilla, AK on July 4, 2015

here we ware 5 years later it still looks and feels like it did when I bought it. No not because I'm skinny in any way. I'm 260lbs and my wife 290. We used to buy a new mattress every few years but this one is amazing!!! →

“Spring Air Back Supporter Latex Hybrid Natalie Ultra Firm - 17030 (wish I could also have the box spring)”

• The Natalie Ultra Firm model from the Spring Air Back Supporter line by Spring Air
• Purchased from Costco

Posted by Percy V from San Luis Obispo, CA on July 15, 2015

When I first ordered this mattress, I got it with the box spring as a set. However, the box spring wouldn't go through my stairs up to my room so I had to return the entire set and re order just the mattress. It would be beneficial to must costumers … →

“Corsicana Brigham Messina Pillowtop - 9873 (Quickly turned BAD)”

• The Messina Pillowtop model from the Corsicana Brigham Collection line by Corsicana
• Purchased from American Bedroom

Posted by Leah from Kountze, TX on March 16, 2015

Bought 1 year ago, started noticing body impression "sagging" within a few months. Waking up though the night with hip pain, so now in search for another mattress. Grrrrrr! →

“Saatva - 10017 (Best nights sleep I have had in years!)”

• The Saatva brand

Posted by Andee from Madison, NJ on March 19, 2015

Extraordinarily impress that I did not have to buy additional toppers to made this bed "perfect" It is, on it's own accord. →

“REM Sleep Paradise - 10449 (Heavenly sleep)”

• The Paradise model by REM Sleep

Posted by Erica from Carson, CA on March 26, 2015

This mattress is AWESOME! We've been looking at this bed and adjustable base for two years. My husband tried it out at a home show and told me I had to try it. As soon as I laid down and they adjusted it to 0 gravity it improved my breathing … →

“Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Classic Pierpont Firm - 10633 (If you need a firm mattress, you won't be disappointed)”

• The Pierpont Firm model from the Beautyrest Recharge line by Beautyrest

Posted by Sam from Atlantic City, NJ on March 29, 2015

I've spent lots of money (2500+) on mattresses in the past. I recently bought a pierpont when I needed a mattress in a second home. I didn't want to spend a lot for a mattress that would get occasional use. I have to say that this mattress is much more … →

“Sleep Innovations NovaForm Primafina - 10708 (This bed does not hold up)”

• The Primafina model from the Sleep Innovations NovaForm line by Sleep Innovations

Posted by Missy from Tillamook, OR on March 30, 2015

We bought this bed in 2012 and the first year was great. The mattress was comfortable and we felt like we made a great purchase. But a few months later the mattress started to dip on both sides which has gotten progressively worse. The dip was more prominent on my … →

“Serta iComfort Insight - 1871 (Love the bed, but strong chemical sell)”

• The Insight model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta

Posted by J H from San Diego, CA on May 3, 2012

Overall my husband and I are pleased with the mattress however it is a lot harder than the one in the store. We were assured that it would soften up, but it has been three months and has hardly changed. I would also agree with the other reviewer that when … →

“Park Place Baroness Firm - 1874 (Don't buy)”

• The Baroness Firm (Extra Firm) model from the Park Place 75th Anniversary line by Park Place

Posted by Tom S from Staunton, VA on May 4, 2012

good support for about 6 weeks. Then sags in the middle. Rotate & flip and it does the same thing. After 7 months of daily use there are no more sag free middle section. I will never buy a Park Place mattres again. Back Pain every morning. I feel ripped … →

“Saatva - 10995 (Only 1 week in.)”

• The Saatva brand

Posted by Jacquie from Curlew, WA on April 4, 2015

I thought I should take a moment to write my first review of my new Saatva mattress and will update it later after 6 months to a year. We have had two different types of memory foam mattresses and were in love with them both for the first couple of … →

“Pure LatexBliss Pamper - 11285 (Latex was not my first choice)”

• The Pamper model from the Pure LatexBliss Natural Latex Collection line by Pure Talalay Bliss

Posted by Paul from San Diego, CA on April 9, 2015

I had a memory foam mattress that was great until I developed a back problem. I needed to get a firm mattress so I could easily get out of or roll over. I purchased a highly rated innerspring mattress which was returned and I went shopping for a firm, not … →

“Corsicana Brigham Medici Eurotop - 20451 (Worst bed I've ever owned)”

• The Medici Eurotop model from the Corsicana Brigham Collection line by Corsicana

Posted by Sarah from Belle Plaine, MN on August 26, 2015

The sides collapsed in less than a year. The bed looks like a hammock and I wake up every day in horrible pain. The bed squeaks so loud with the slightest movement. We are not heavy people either (135 & 160). Biggest waste of money we ever spent. →

“TEMPUR-Cloud (Pre-2014) - 12743 (So far it has changed my life!)”

• The TEMPUR-Cloud (Pre-2014) line by TEMPUR-Pedic
• Purchased from Sweet Dreams Mattress (Mooresville, NC)

Posted by NC from Mooresville, NC on May 6, 2015

We upgraded from a Serta Innerspring Mattress from 2000 when we were first married. What a difference! The sales team at Sweet Dreams was professional and focused on the best bed to meet our needs. We felt no pressure to buy at all and the shopping experience was positively wonderful. … →

“Select Comfort Sleep Number 7000 Bed - 13026 (LOVE IT!)”

• The Sleep Number 7000 Bed model by Sleep Number
• Purchased from Sleep Number Bed Store

Posted by Shell from Little Elm, TX on May 12, 2015

Took me a few months to REALLY dial in my number, but once I got it, best night's sleep I've ever had. Sleeps as good today as the day we bought it 10 yrs ago. →

“Octaspring 6500 - 19752 (thought it would be better than last tempur-pedic )”

• The 6500 model from the Dormeo Octaspring line by Dormeo

Posted by Robert from Saint Augustine, FL on August 19, 2015

I have several herniated discs in my back and suffer through a good night's sleep. My old Tempur-Pedic was great except it would get hot and certain extra curricular activities were difficult due to the sinking. When it finally reached it's due age I decided to try something new. After … →

“Sealy Amici Select Firm - 21313 (Best Bed )”

• The Amici Select Firm model by Sealy

Posted by Christine from Houston, TX on September 5, 2015

Two years ago I bought another Sears mattress about 8 inches thick and less coils. I was in constant pain. The Amuci mattress is 12 inches thick and twice the coils. I am using it with a metal spring frame. Super comfortable. No aches and pains. Great support. Great for … →

“Therapedic Crescendo Euro Top - 21652 (Rooms To Go was gracious to exchange my Therapedic Cresce...)”

• The Crescendo Euro Top model by Therapedic
• Purchased from Rooms To Go

Posted by Cindy from Lexington, SC on September 7, 2015

Rooms To Go was gracious to exchange my Therapedic Crescendo for another one just like it because it started sagging in the areas we lay after six months. We are of average weight. Now, I have to call the service rep to come out again and measure the dip. Hopeful … →

“Hampton & Rhodes - 23333 (We bought a Hampton and Rhodes Cushion Firm and love it )”

• The Hampton & Rhodes brand

Posted by Farmer from Mountlake Terrace, WA on September 26, 2015

We needed a new bed our first we bought was a Posturepedic Camerion Cushion Firm. Want to talk about sleeping on a ROCK. I hated it! Wanted something more like our old bed which was innerspring. Sadly all that was available was Hampton and Rhodes. Had never heard of it … →

“Serta iComfort Hybrid Advisor Pillowtop - 176269 (Poor Value For The Money)”

• The Advisor Pillowtop model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta

Posted by Scott from Hillsboro, OR on August 21, 2017

At first, this mattress seemed amazing. Not too firm, not too soft. It supported my body, kept me relatively cool at night, and I slept like the dead. After just 3 months of ownership I noticed the fill in the pillow top getting bunched up, and now that it's over … →

“Sleep EZ Naturale 8.5" Latex - 140406 (Saved Me From Doctor visits and Physical Therapy Weekly)”

• The Naturale 8.5" Latex model from the Sleep EZ Select Sleep line by Sleep EZ

Posted by Andrew from Mesa, AZ on May 5, 2017

I easily paid ten times the cost of this mattress trying to find back pain relief from herniated disks. The doctors wanted to do surgery everyone had a different solution that did not work and I knew that the mattress that I was sleeping at the time definitely was not … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Caversham 10" Firm - 190878 (Mattress had great support originally.)”

• The Caversham 10" Firm model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Gerald from Sun City, AZ on September 28, 2017

After about 6 months of sleeping on the mattress, I felt its support start to diminish. After 15 months, its support is worse than the one we replaced that was over 20 years old. We will soon need to replace the mattress due to loss of sleep because of my … →

“Kingsdown Delmonico Firm - 293522 (Very Disappointing)”

• The Delmonico Firm model by Kingsdown

Posted by Samantha from Binbrook, ON on July 14, 2018

I wish I was writing a great review as I really wanted to love this mattress. 1st purchase as a single mom, I've had this king mattress/box spring set for 1.5 yrs. Its been the worst mattress I've ever owned and I always pay a lot due to having a … →

“Corsicana Harmony - 310393 (Fantastic sleep for a while.....but)”

• The Corsicana Harmony line by Corsicana

Posted by Josh from Watervliet, MI on September 4, 2018

Really we loved this mattress. Problem is that it started sagging. We argued about how long we'd owned it. 7 years? 10 years? Either way we thought short enough to be disappointed, long enough to not feel too bad. But then I found the manufacture tag and realized we'd owned … →

“TEMPUR-Cloud Select (2012) - 291150 (When we first got this bed, we loved it. It was definitel...)”

• The Cloud Select model from the TEMPUR-Cloud Collection (Pre-2014) line by TEMPUR-Pedic

Posted by Tonua from Georgetown, KY on July 6, 2018

When we first got this bed, we loved it. It was definitely better than our previous bed, and my husband slept without back pain for the first time in a long time. We got it for his back pain, and it was definitely an improvement for him. I prefer a … →

“Serta Grovelawn Super Pillowtop - 366673 (Hammock Hell)”

• The Grovelawn Super Pillowtop model from the Serta iDirections line by Serta

Posted by shazzer from Macomb, MI on April 5, 2019

We were so excited to get this hybrid...the wedding cakes of all beds! After the first 9 months we started to notice our backs were not as supported as when we first brought this mattress home. It was so comfortable, supportive and snugly, bugly! As the months passed we started … →

“Kingsdown Sleeping Beauty Ashleigh Plush - 170664 (Ashleigh Plush Pit)”

• The Ashleigh Plush model from the Kingsdown Sleeping Beauty line by Kingsdown
• Purchased from Sleepy's

Posted by Rick from Medford, NJ on August 7, 2017

This matress was great the first year that we had it. Over the course of the second year a pit has developed in the middle of the bed to th epoint where we have to grab the edge of the mattress to pull ourselves out of bed in the morning. … →

“Ikea Sultan Hanestad - 191621 (Mattress does not last)”

• The Sultan Hanestad model by IKEA

Posted by Madeleyne from San Diego, CA on October 1, 2017

I got this mattress about 2 years ago. When I first got it it was great, now it's so crappy, I can feel the springs, and sometimes I hear like stuff is breaking inside. The mattress feels so lumpy now (when I first got it it had some firmness to … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Waterston II Plush Euro Top - 171348 (Actuallyb CAUSES back pain)”

• The Waterston II Plush Euro Top model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy
• Purchased from Sears

Posted by DUKE from Amarillo, TX on August 9, 2017

This mattress started out ok, but in about 6 months, began to crater. It has gotten progressively worse as time goes on. The pillowtop is comfortable, but the guts are disintegrating, leaving a very firm edge. It's like trying to escape from a trap. SEARS won't even talk to me … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Mountain Vale Plush - 93631 (Sagging mattress)”

• The Mountain Vale Plush model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Joseph from Monroe, GA on November 14, 2016

Have had this mattress warrantied multiple times. It is a waste of your money, my inlaws had the same mattress we bought at the same time. They had theirs warrantied 4 times before discarding it and buying a different mattress. Ours is good for six months then it sags. They … →

“Sleep to Live - 160280 (Ridge in middle of bed, worthless warranty)”

• The Sleep to Live line by Kingsdown
• Purchased from Sleepy's

Posted by Judith from Tuckerton, NJ on July 8, 2017

The first 2 or so years it was pretty good support. The 3rd year it became less comfortable. We contacted the company and they said it was naturally going to have the impressions of the way you sleep in it. There was nothing they could do. We also told them … →

“Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image - 1879 (Perfect Sleep - CMG Caress)”

• The Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image line by Carolina Mattress Guild
• Purchased from Rooms To Go (Frisco, TX)

Posted by Larry P from Allen, TX on May 7, 2012

It's been about 2 months since we purchased our CMG Caress (King) from RTG. I do have to say after reading some of the negative reviews I was paranoid for the first month constantly asking my wife, "do you think it's sagging on my side", all the while I was … →

“Serta iComfort Prodigy Plush - 1680 (Pathetic icomfort Prodigy mattress)”

• The Prodigy Plush model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta
• Purchased from Brooks Furniture (Winter Haven, FL)

Posted by Roger C from Fort Meade, FL on November 9, 2011

The Prodigy mattress is pathetic! I weigh 260 pounds and in 5 weeks my Prodigy Queen turned into mush! In the store and for the first week it was wonderful. My back loved it! I changed sides every 2-3 days to equalize wear but it still turned into mush in … →

“Beautyrest Dreamwell - 125287 (Like sleeping in a bowl)”

• The Dreamwell model by Beautyrest

Posted by Charles from Chesterfield, VA on March 10, 2017

Mattress started out great but it definetily has cupped in the middle I'm 180 lbs wife is 130 and keep finding myself on her side, it seems well made but does hurt the back because of the cupping. Paid $1300 for complete bed, frame box spring all From Simmons ! … →

“Kingsdown Juliet Cushion Firm - 139592 (Waste of materials and money!)”

• The Juliet Cushion Firm model by Kingsdown

Posted by Ron from Bluffton, SC on May 2, 2017

Considering the reputation and cost of the Kingsdown king mattress, I expected far more than it has delivered. Initially, it was comfortable, supportive, and I was pleased. But,within a year, it was starting to feel like it was sagging and breaking down. Plus, I am about 220 lbs. and my … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Steinbach Euro Top - 188077 (Terrible investment - A hard lesson to learn)”

• The Steinbach Euro Top model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Peter from Omaha, NE on September 19, 2017

I bought this mattress as my first mattress out of college. It was great for the first 6 months to a year. However, after only owning it for 2 years, I had to replace it. It dips severely in the middle and I wake up with back pain every single … →

“Bed Boss - 39974 (I believe a mattress with about 4-6" of foam on top of a ...)”

• The Bed Boss brand

Posted by Nola R from Valdese, NC on January 26, 2016

I believe a mattress with about 4-6" of foam on top of a firm mattress would fit my comfort zone and sleep patterns better. If I move to the middle of my mattress there is plenty of support then during sleep I tend to roll back into the hammock area … →

“Southard - 40176 (Waterbed)”

• The Southard brand

Posted by Mike from Port Charlotte, FL on January 27, 2016

Robert was a huge help. He helped me pick the right Waterbed mattress for me and without any pressure to buy. →

“Jaclyn Smith - 40189 (Best bed I have ever owned)”

• The Jaclyn Smith line by King Koil

Posted by Helen R on January 27, 2016

Our bed is a 'Regal Luxury' Jaclyn Smith 'Home' by King Koil Other people have slept on this bed from time to time over the years, inlaws & friends when house sitting for us and they always rave about how comfortable our bed is. I bought it on sale 12 … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Prichard Ultra Firm - 40218 (It' great for anyone with back problems)”

• The Prichard Ultra Firm model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Kevin A from Tempe, AZ on January 27, 2016

I'm glad i purchase this mattress and for the price it was a steal. anyone with back problems should check this mattress out. →

“Stearns & Foster Luxury Villa La Rosa Cushion Firm - 42136 (the bed sink in the middle)”

• The Villa La Rosa Cushion Firm model from the Stearns & Foster Luxury Collection line by Stearns & Foster

Posted by Lyn from Torrance, CA on February 6, 2016

I love the bed very comfortable but it's Sink in the middle I had to sleep on the edges which does not sink but it forces you back to the middle the bed is very comfortable but no support in the middle after 4 years I'm returning the bed →

“Stearns & Foster Silver Dream Ultra Plush Boxtop - 42195 (Fantastic bed when new but disappointing over time...)”

• The Silver Dream Ultra Plush Boxtop model from the Stearns & Foster Silver Dream line by Stearns & Foster

Posted by Sylvia R from Florence, MA on February 7, 2016

For the first 5 years, this bed was everything I had hoped it would be: just right in the areas of warmth, softness/firmness, comfort... Great for side-sleeping and no discomfort on my hips or back. But, as mentioned, it began to sag in the middle after only 5 years. Sleeping … →

“Loom & Leaf Relaxed Firm - 43709 (Love our Loom & Leaf)”

• The Loom & Leaf Relaxed Firm model by Loom & Leaf

Posted by Theresa from Flint, TX on February 13, 2016

I couldn't wait another day to share our L & L experience. We had a 10 year old coil mattress that was causing us much pain and grief each night. So like many, we began our search for a new mattress. I am thrilled we chose as we did and … →

“Southerland Kimball Plush Pillowtop - 70846 (Great for first year then back breaker)”

• The Kimball Plush Pillowtop model by Southerland

Posted by Anonymous from Omaha, NE on July 12, 2016

This mattress was very comfortable for the first year. 2 1/2 years later the middle is sagging significantly-causing severe back pain and several dr appts/X-rays etc. purchased two of these beds-never again →

“IKEA HESSTUN - 71256 (I liked it better out of the bag)”

• The HESSTUN model by IKEA

Posted by Joann from Deltona, FL on July 14, 2016

I have had this mattress (spring version) for two or three months - plenty of time to break it in. To be honest, I liked it much better right out of the bag. It is not a rolled mattress - comes full sized in a well-packaged bag. It was firm … →

“Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Medium (2015-2020) - 84991 (Good for a couple of months ... But then????)”

• The Alexander Signature Medium (2015-2020) model from the Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Series (2015-2020) line by Nest Bedding

Posted by Chuck S from Graham, TX on September 11, 2016

Dips in the mattress where we lay. Very middle is much higher. →

“Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Medium (2015-2020) - 86063 (The softest medium firm mattress ever!)”

• The Alexander Signature Medium (2015-2020) model from the Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Series (2015-2020) line by Nest Bedding

Posted by Summer S from Ozark, MO on September 15, 2016

I expected a touch below firm for this mattress. It was very good the first month. Now both my husband and I turn frequently at night, which we never did before. I'm even sore now. I never thought foam could get saggy but this company found a way. I still … →

“Nature's Rest Sunrise Firm - 1918 (Horrible Mattress)”

• The Sunrise Firm model by Nature's Rest
• Purchased from American Factory Direct Furniture Outlet

Posted by A.N. F from Nesconset, NY on June 12, 2012

We bought this mattress on sale as a tempurpedic alternative, with the traditional bed look and feel. The first month was great, it gave the support needed and we slept like babies! We rotated the mattress as needed, and as it started losing support, we even flipped it over, and … →

“Nature's Rest - 1540 (2K for 2 months of quality)”

• The Nature's Rest brand
• Purchased from Sleepy's (Branford, CT)

Posted by Jack A from Guilford, CT on July 2, 2011

Purchased the Nature's Rest from Sleepy's for ~2K. It had a high rating for being hypoallergenic. My wife and I noticed saging within the first 2 months (my wife and I's combined weight is 325 lbs.). By around the 3 month mark, it had 2+ inch depressions. Replaced it for … →

“Therapedic i-care Elite - 313067 (hype, just hype,don't believe the hype)”

• The Therapedic i-care Elite line by Therapedic

Posted by James from Philadelphia, PA on September 13, 2018

Beautiful and firm like I wanted was the Therapedic I-care bliss full size mattress. The back was feeling great for a short time, until the mattress valley started to appear in the middle of the mattress. After (2) two months, the valley could be noticed, and I have pictures. It … →

“TEMPUR-Contour Elite (2014) - 388884 (Ahhh to ooh!)”

• The Contour Elite model from the TEMPUR-Contour Collection (Pre-2014) line by TEMPUR-Pedic

Posted by Samuel from Antioch, TN on July 22, 2019

It was heavenly in the beginning. It was more than a honeymoon, that bed felt firm yet supple for a three years. Lately it's been a lot less supportive. A bed's support should outlast it's payment cycle. I admit, that I am hard to please due to back problems and … →

“TEMPUR-Cloud (2010) - 419703 (Sad)”

• The Cloud (2010) model from the TEMPUR-Cloud Collection (Pre-2014) line by TEMPUR-Pedic

Posted by Anna from Spokane, WA on December 17, 2019

After 9 years of bliss, my Tempurpedic Cloud is wearing out. The memory foam is flattening and overall is getting lumpy. Over $4k it's sad it needs to be replaced already. →

Complaints for Initial Support

“Pure Talalay Bliss - 1849 (Unfortunately, this did not work.)”

• The Pure Talalay Bliss brand

Posted by David R from Los Angeles, CA on April 17, 2012

Can a mattress be both too soft and too firm at the same time? It appears so. From the very day that my PLB mattress arrived, things did not seem "right." When laying on either the left or right side of the bed, I had the sensation of being on … →

“Simmons BeautyRest World Class Whitehaven Visco 200 Pillowtop - 1880 (HORRIBLE HORRIBLE HORRIBLE)”

• The Whitehaven Visco 200 Pillowtop model from the Beautyrest World Class (Pre-2014) line by Beautyrest

Posted by Josh B from Carlisle, PA on May 7, 2012

This product will give you severe back pain, and will fall apart. This product retails at Mattress Warehouse which is where I bought this for 1200.00. They have replaced it twice now and will not return my money, just give me the same junk product. I will never buy another … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Prichard Ultra Firm - 12223 (A slight adjustment if you come from plush.)”

• The Prichard Ultra Firm model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Dan from Gresham, OR on April 25, 2015

I had a rather plush bed prior, and I thought it would not work at first yet in a couple of days my back adjusted nicely, I haven't had a problem since. The quality is outstanding for there price. →

“Serta Delicate Moon - 314119 (I hate this mattress)”

• The Delicate Moon model by Serta

Posted by Tracy from Tampa, FL on September 18, 2018

I hate this mattress more than I have ever known it was possible to hate a mattress. It’s awful. The support was gone immediately and they replaced it within 6 months. Now I have the same awful mattress and am looking for a new one as I prefer sleeping on … →

“Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Classic Candace Plush Pillowtop - 3720 (Worth the money, good support, pleasant decor, with overal B)”

• The Candace Plush Pillowtop model from the Beautyrest Recharge line by Beautyrest
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Jason D from Hamtramck, MI on August 5, 2014

Will serve as sufficient bedding for many years with ample comfort & durability. →

“Beautyrest - 3728 (Good product for price )”

• The Beautyrest brand
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Marilyn I from Southfield, MI on August 5, 2014

I feel that the mattress is comfortable and hope that it will still be comfortable a few years from now. →

“Simmons W Hotels Pillow Top - 4224 (Warranty not honored!)”

• The W Hotels Pillow Top model by Beautyrest

Posted by Stacey from Boxford, MA on October 9, 2014

Our king size W Hotel Bed by Simmons from Sleepy's arrived on 6/16/13. We had slept on them in hotels and loved them. However, this one seemed a little off from the beginning but we thought perhaps it was just a matter of breaking it in. Unfortunately, a year and … →

“Beautyrest Dreamwell - 6240 (HORRIBLE BED)”

• The Dreamwell model by Beautyrest

Posted by Debora from West Point, VA on January 15, 2015

My first Simmons Beautyrest Dreamwell Cliff Haven Plush Pillow Top was replaced after just 3 months. This is the second mattress I've had for about 1 year and today has been inspected. Shows obvious 2 inch sink in middle. Back and neck problems have now escalated due to this poorly … →

“Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Classic Pontevedra - 6828 (Worst Mattress Ever + Significant Back Pain)”

• The Pontevedra model from the Beautyrest Recharge line by Beautyrest

Posted by AL from Mesa, AZ on January 24, 2015

I have had (2) replacements of this mattress from the American Furniture Warehouse in a period of just a few months. I have had the same issue with each of the mattresses and am having the second one returned in order to purchase another mattress brand all together. I have … →

“Kathy Ireland European Country Porte de Jardin Pillowtop - 14027 (sinking on both sides months after purchasing)”

• The Porte de Jardin Pillowtop model from the Kathy Ireland by Therapedic line by Therapedic

Posted by Sheila from Heathsville, VA on May 27, 2015

I have 2 3.5 inch dents in the mattress, and our backs are killing us. No help from company, an unfortunately we don't have money to replace right now. Horrible mattress!! →

“Serta iComfort Insight - 15690 (awful)”

• The Insight model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta
• Purchased from Raymour & Flanigan (Lake Grove, NY)

Posted by Jessica from Coram, NY on June 27, 2015

we purchased this bed from the store in july 2014. when we tried this in the showroom, we were over the moon. after a few years with an innerspring that just wasn't doing it, this was absolutely wonderful. what arrived at our door was a totally different story. it was … →

“iSleep Sleep Adjustment Bed - 10770 (Terrible bed. Did not honor refund either.)”

• The Sleep Adjustment Bed model by iSleep

Posted by Kari from Rock Springs, WY on March 31, 2015

Called Isleep because my chiropractor claimed it was a great bed. Talked with the salesman, Lynn, about the bed for a bit and asked if it came with a metal frame so we wouldn't have to go buy a new one, Lynn stated it did. Received bed, metal frame was … →

“Serta iComfort Savant Plush - 11369 (Pain and numbness still there)”

• The Savant Plush model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta

Posted by Diane from Depew, NY on April 11, 2015

when i went looking for new bed that would stop my hip pain and my shoulder pain-numbness in my arm and fingers, i thought i found the right bed or so i was lead to believe it would be. it isn't. i am a few days short of the 30 … →

“Spring Air Back Supporter Latex Hybrid Natalie Ultra Firm - 18074 (Firmness fails after just a month or so)”

• The Natalie Ultra Firm model from the Spring Air Back Supporter line by Spring Air
• Purchased from Costco

Posted by Sandra B from La Center, WA on July 30, 2015

I weigh 160 lbs and am 5'9". I have a bulging disk. When I lay on my left side the mattress sinks in by my hip and causes the bulge to be pinched and leaves me with excruciating pain. It is not quite so bad n my right side but … →

“Aireloom Handcrafted - 18691 (It's a SICK joke!)”

• The Aireloom Handcrafted line by Aireloom

Posted by Andrew from Minneapolis, MN on August 7, 2015

Way too much money for a terrible quality mattress. Right from the beginning it's been night after night of restless sleep and every morning when my wife and I wake up we have terrible back pain. Would not give to a homeless man I would feel terrible for him. It … →

“Serta iComfort Hybrid Applause II Plush - 322020 (Harder than the showroom bed)”

• The Applause II Plush model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta

Posted by Sally from Wilmington, NC on October 19, 2018

Right away I noticed a huge difference in the bed they delivered and the one I tried in the showroom. After confirming it was the same model and the one I ordered and tried, I was told there is a break-in period. So I accepted that and learned to live … →

“TEMPUR-Flex - 135625 (Expensive, Hard and Hot)”

• The TEMPUR-Flex line by TEMPUR-Pedic

Posted by Charlotte from Waterloo, IA on April 17, 2017

Tempur Flex is expensive to buy, it is firm - hard and contrary to what I was told at purchase, it has not "broken in", after several months it remains too firm. Also, the mattress retains body heat and is hot to sleep on. In a nut shell, $$ to … →

“Stewart & Hamilton - 46360 (I have a queen and a full size awful not one night good s...)”

• The Stewart & Hamilton brand

Posted by Devetta T from North Charleston, SC on February 24, 2016

I have a queen and a full size awful not one night good sleep and they're falling apart this company will never receive my money again and won't receive any money from anybody that I know again →

“Sealy Avery Plush Euro Top - 375083 (Swallowed Up)”

• The Avery Plush Euro Top model by Sealy

Posted by PJ on May 18, 2019

A mattress should last more than four and a half years. Bought a foundation for it to make sure it was supported, but they don’t make mattresses like they used to. Comfortable when you first get in and yet within a few minutes you realize it’s just not firm enough. … →

“Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) - 25460 (Not at all like what's in the store)”

• The Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Large from Red Bank, NJ on October 21, 2015

Horrible experience - the mattress felt pretty soft (it is a firm mattress, but I like a little plush) in the store, but when it arrived at home, it's hard as a rock. Manufacturing defect? Sears was NOT good about returning it, nor was Sealy. Apparently, their warranty doesn't cover … →

“Kingsdown Sleeping Beauty Celine - 26504 (not supportive, lumpy and saggy within 3 months)”

• The Celine model from the Kingsdown Sleeping Beauty line by Kingsdown
• Purchased from Sleep Country Canada

Posted by Erin from Stouffville, ON on November 3, 2015

This bed is not supportive at all, and within 3 months of purcase was lumpy and sagging in the middle despite frequent rotation. Causes back and hip pain as difficult to roll over during sleep and you sink into mattress. Not recommended for anyone with back issues or who prefers … →

“Noah's - 28981 (Totally dissatisfied)”

• The Noah's brand

Posted by Elaine from Portage la Prairie, MB on November 25, 2015

Started getting bad back aches 9 months after purchase, Sleep Country has given us nothing but a hard time . Told us to send pictures and never got back to us. The salesman never told us about needing a new frame for this mattress at purchase. When delivered the guys … →

“Dormeo - 143996 (Severely disappointed customer)”

• The Dormeo brand

Posted by Ana from Glendale, AZ on May 19, 2017

My Husband thought he was doing us both a favor by buying a cushioned firm mattress Dormeo 230GX king and because of the cost $4008.00 it would be good quality. Nothing has been good about this mattress. We have only had it for 7 months and are both miserable and … →

“Serta Perfect Sleeper Sorento Super Pillow Top - 40676 (painful I sleep on the couch)”

• The Sorento Super Pillow Top model from the Serta Perfect Sleeper (Pre-2019) line by Serta

Posted by Larry from Fort Collins, CO on January 30, 2016

We had painful backs right away we put a 3 inch memory foam pad on it which was slightly better I sleep on the couch most nights my back will not relax in any position on this mattress it was a waste of money →

“Ethan Allen Serenity Firm - 41721 (Not worth the $$)”

• The Serenity Firm model by Ethan Allen
• Purchased from Ethan Allen (Hartsdale, NY)

Posted by Anthony from Bronx, NY on February 4, 2016

Initially the mattress provided me with the comfort and firmness that I wanted but within 18 months that quickly deteriorated. I contacted customer service and they immediately sent a technician over to my house to evaluate the mattress. After the technician's evaluation I was awarded a full in store credit … →

“Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid Medium (2015-2020) - 260478 (Poor support)”

• The Alexander Signature Hybrid Medium (2015-2020) model from the Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid (2015-2020) line by Nest Bedding

Posted by Amber S from Tulsa, OK on April 4, 2018

This is my second Alexander mattress. The first started sagging shortly after purchase. The warranty claim process was simple. I received a new mattress quickly. The new mattress has also started sagging, however, and I’m very unhappy with the purchase. The mattress at first seems absolutely perfect- it’s soft yet … →

“Ashley Sleep Addison Shore - 304271 (Waking up nightly with acute pain)”

• The Addison Shore model by Ashley Sleep

Posted by Jon from Mocksville, NC on August 19, 2018

I bought a extended warranty from Ashley in Winston Salem and they told me the entire bed was under complete warranty for 5 years. I called them and I was telling them I have been waking up for about a year in acute pain in my hip from the innerspring, … →

“Stearns & Foster Kirkland Signature Hope Bay - 444032 (Weak springs...not recommended for over 150lbs)”

• The Hope Bay model from the Stearns & Foster Kirkland Signature line by Stearns & Foster

Posted by Brado from Glendale, CA on April 6, 2020

Have now tried all the "S" brands including Serta, Seely & now Sterns & Fost...it seems like all the manufactures don't use quality metal in their springs that is resilent like in the old days. Beds used to be made so you could "flip" them...but not anymore...this is "progress" I'm … →

“Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Classic Linden Forest - 469671 (Doesn't Last, Poor Performance for a Luxury Firm Mattress)”

• The Linden Forest model from the Beautyrest Recharge line by Beautyrest

Posted by Charles from Littleton, CO on July 25, 2020

Had to purchase a new mattress as my wife and I haven't been sleeping well on this Recharge Linden Forest. Discovered ours was only 6 years old (8 year warranty). Beautyrest doesn't honor the warranty. →

“Beautyrest Platinum Haven Pines Luxury Firm - 537359 (Sags in less than a year)”

• The Haven Pines Luxury Firm model from the Beautyrest Platinum (2016-2019) line by Beautyrest

Posted by J from Sycamore, IL on July 13, 2021

It was amazing for the first 2 months. Then we kept rotating it as suggested but it developed ruts where we sleep. My husband is 180lbs and it still made a dent. I would not buy it again and hope I can get it replaced. →

“DreamCloud (2020-2022) - 557841 (Great - but doesn't last.)”

• The DreamCloud (2020-2022) model by DreamCloud

Posted by Reed from Yarmouth, ME on December 10, 2021

Mattress felt great at first, but less than 6 months in, the support foams felt like they were failing. Less than 3 years in we're replacing it, after multiple times trying to contact the company to see if there was a warranty issue with zero response. Would never recommend. →

“Simmons Beautyrest World Class Resonance Plush - 560011 (Disappointed in product. Only about year and half old and...)”

• The Resonance Plush model from the Beautyrest World Class (Pre-2014) line by Beautyrest

Posted by Joseph C from Woburn, MA on December 30, 2021

Disappointed in product. Only about year and half old and started sinking in where each person slept. Very obvious to the eye even with Comforter on the bed. Did all that was necessary in filing a Warranty Claim including having an Inspection done in my home. My claim was denied … →

“Southerland Collection - 581101 (Sagging after a few months)”

• The Southerland line by Southerland

Posted by Lou from Mesa, AZ on July 3, 2022

Was good when I bought it. But after a few months began to visibly have indentation and no support. →

“Boyd Night Air - 586550 (Terrible Customer Service - Won't return calls / emails)”

• The Boyd Night Air line by Boyd

Posted by Kelly from Chino Hills, CA on August 21, 2022

We have had the mattress, for almost 8 weeks. The mattress will not hold air consistently. One side seems to lose air worse then the other. We have done everything the troubleshooting guide tells you to, and it still happens. we have reset the pump, hand tightened the hose connections … →

“Beautyrest Hybrid BRX1000-IP Plush - 589785 (3 yrs in, need a new mattress)”

• The BRX1000-IP Plush model from the Beautyrest Hybrid (2019-2021) line by Beautyrest

Posted by Justin from Syracuse, NY on September 14, 2022

Took me a month to get my back used to this bed, my wife was fine right away. Over the past year, both of us are walking up with sore backs and hips. Warranty is if there is 3/4” sag, there might be half that right now, but this mattress … →

“Badcock Legends - 598049 (Very depressing and causing sleeplessness)”

• The Badcock Legends line by Badcock

Posted by Tammie from Warner Robins, GA on December 6, 2022

I can't sleep due to being very uncomfortable. It's like sleep on something that's caving in on me. Badcock should be held accountable. I'm still paying for this garbage of a mattress that I've had less than a year. →

“Hampton & Rhodes Grand Harbor Ultra Plush Pillowtop - 598323 (Just want a good nights sleep)”

• The Grand Harbor Ultra Plush Pillowtop model from the Hampton & Rhodes line by Hampton & Rhodes

Posted by Margie from Benton, PA on December 10, 2022

Never knew I had back issues until this mattress. Every morning is a stiff and aching back so I am guessing it is to soft for me, which I didn’t think was possible. About a year ago I flipped the mattress over and has been sleeping on the bottom of … →

“Marshall - 608031 (Overpriced for Comfort quality)”

• The Marshall brand

Posted by Vera from Vernon, BC on March 12, 2023

I expected a comfortable sleep for this price point. I have to flip this mattress every month for impressions and it's heavy. I'm 140lbs and the only one that sleeps on it. There was one level softer at time of purchase but I wanted support so I went one lower … →

“Sleep to Live 500 - 614520 (Horrible Torturous Bed)”

• The 500 model from the Sleep to Live line by Kingsdown

Posted by Nancy from Portland, OR on May 22, 2023

My husband and I slept on a Sealy Posturpedic for almost 20 years and it was only the last few years that it was uncomfortable. So we're older and thought, We'll get a really good bed as it might be our last one. Lol. Bought a Kingsdown and I am … →

“Simmons Beautyrest Silver Waterscape Plush Pillowtop - 615893 (Started off Great)”

• The Waterscape Plush Pillowtop model from the Beautyrest Silver (2017-2019) line by Beautyrest

Posted by allan from Tappan, NY on June 5, 2023

After 5 years there is no support in the mattress. →

“Serta Perfect Sleeper Hotel Sapphire Suite II Plush Pillowtop Double Sided - 616677 (Another sleepless night)”

• The Sapphire Suite II Plush Pillowtop Double Sided model from the Serta Perfect Sleeper (Pre-2019) line by Serta

Posted by Cheryl from Phelan, CA on June 15, 2023

We've had this for four years. Two years in I knew it was not worth the paper I paid for it. The layers shifted so that the vertical sides at head and foot are slanted in opposite directions. Any support it once provided is gone. I never had hip pain … →

“Simmons Brittany Luxury Firm - 620296 (Quickly Worn)”

• The Brittany Luxury Firm model by Beautyrest

Posted by DJ from Plano, TX on July 24, 2023

We purchased a Brittany Lux Platinum Firm mattress in June 2016 and it started sagging in the middle on each side about 3 years ago. I have had chronic sciatica for many years and have finally realized that this mattress has been the cause of many of my very painful … →

“Southerland Amerigel - 620376 (Terrible bed)”

• The Southerland line by Southerland

Posted by Mark from Phoenix, AZ on July 25, 2023

My Southerland Essex mattress started to dip/sag in the middle and sides almost immediately after buying. No support whatsoever, It’s almost 1 year old and I am throwing it away. Goodbye to $1700. Funny how the floor model in showroom was so comfy and supporting. I honestly don’t think they … →

“Spink & Co - 621885 (Pressure points)”

• The Spink & Co brand

Posted by Debbie from York, ME on August 11, 2023

The mattress was a little to firm for me. So I got latex topper which helped a lot. I noticed after a year I could see impressions on the bed. Two years later were uncomfortable on this mattress due to pressure points on shoulders and hip. Thought it was the … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Plus High Point Firm ("Ultimate Support + Cooling" Hybrid) - 623341 (Misrepresented in Mattress Store)”

• The High Point Firm ("Ultimate Support + Cooling" Hybrid) model from the Sealy Posturepedic Plus (2021-2025) line by Sealy

Posted by Laura from Los Angeles, CA on August 27, 2023

I was looking for a bed with better support after my very expensive high end bed support core failed after one year and the company denied my warranty claim. I was sinking very far down in the bed and waking up in severe pain hips, neck, shoulders, lower back. I … →

“Stewart & Hamilton - 623526 (Wish I Would Have Invested More)”

• The Stewart & Hamilton brand

Posted by Liz from Milwaukee, WI on August 29, 2023

I bought this mattress out of a warehouse with a boxspring included in the deal. It sagged within 6 months, even with me turning the mattress. I got what I paid for I guess. It wasn't bad when it was just me sleeping on it, but once my partner moved … →

“Beautyrest PressureSmart Lux 2.0 - 630285 (DO NOT PURCHASE THIS MATTRESS IF YOU VALUE YOUR HEALTH!)”

• The PressureSmart 2.0 line by Beautyrest

Posted by Andrew from Sebastian, FL on November 28, 2023

Buying this mattress was the biggest mistake I've ever made in my entire life. After just 8 months of using this mattress it began sagging so much that it is causing my wife and I severe back pains. We tried working with Mattress Firm and Beauty Rest (Simmons Serta Bedding) … →

“Purple Hybrid - 635886 (Model 4 Purple is Junk Long-Term)”

• The Purple Hybrid line by Purple

Posted by Robert from Signal Mountain, TN on February 13, 2024

The Purple brand has been a huge disappointment in the long run. My wife and I extensively tested several brands at the store and Purple seemed to edge out Tempur-pedic in terms of comfort and price. The bed was great for the first 6 months or so also. I compared … →

“Beautyrest PressureSmart 2.0 - 639143 (Only had this mattress for about two weeks. Not real happy.)”

• The PressureSmart 2.0 line by Beautyrest

Posted by Don from Pittsburgh, PA on April 1, 2024

Only had this mattress for about two weeks. Not real happy. Keep reading you have to let it break in. My body hurts more than before with my old mattress. Don't know. Guess will have to kept giving it time. Supposedly it's a good mattress. Have back issues and, hip. … →