Close button Close Menu

Hi, I have a Sealy south court plush european pillow top, queen sized mattress. (2010) I contacted sealy about a warranty claim, which they are accepting and will offer me a new mattress, and they are telling me the comparable model series is the Sealy Essentials line. Those seem to be the bottom line model. I bought my mattress in 2010, and paid over 700 for it. I don't think the essentials line is actually comparable, I think it's more like their Performance series. Is there something you know about this? I really don't want to shafted by them. Thank you for anything you can help me with on this.

asked Oct 25 '17
Ripjack13's gravatar image
Ripjack13 from Andover, CT
  • 0 karma
  • 0 answers
  • average

Hi Ripjack13 -- Thanks for your question. When going back this far in the Sealy line, determining which is the most comparable mattress available today is more art than science. Here are the realities:

  • There is nothing in today's Sealy line that is exactly like what you had.
  • When comparing specs over time, be aware that features that start out as premium features when they are first introduced to the market eventually become standard features and over a period of several product cycles (e.g., 6-8 years) might even make their way all the way down to entry level models.

In light of those realities, as well as some other facts we can bring to bear in this case, here are a few things to consider, both in support of your argument and against it.

Arguments supporting your case:

  • According to our records, the Sealy South Court Plush was in their Posturepedic line. The Posturepedic line was definitely not the entry level for all of Sealy's products at that time. The entry level models at that time were under the "Sealy Brand" product line, above which the Posturepedic line began. Today's entry level, as you pointed out, is Sealy Essentials, above which is the Performance Series.
  • I think the South Court was in the Reserve Series, which was the middle level of Posturepedic options at that time (Preferred, Reserve, Signature).
  • Price points for the current Response (innerspring) Essentials line generally run from $299-$699 for a queen set, while price points for the Response Performance line tend to be concentrated more in the $699-$1099 range. So, the price you paid of $700 for a queen (esp when adjusted for inflation to, say, $750) falls just above where the Essentials line tends to top out and more at the beginning of the Performance line.

Arguments supporting Sealy's case:

  • Within each line, the range of prices will depend in part on how much cushioning it has. As such, the beginning price point of a line is usually a firm tight top model, and a plush pillow-top model like the one you have tends to be at least 20% more. As such, the price of a plush pillow top in the Essentials line (basically the top of the line Essentials model) is likely to be a little closer in price to what you paid than the least expensive plush pillow top in the Performance line.
  • This mattress was made before Sealy began offering pocketed coils in its mattresses. As such, your mattress features a connected coil support unit. The type of coil system is certainly one of the defining characteristics of an innerspring mattress, and the coils in your mattress tend to more closely resemble what is offered in the Response Essentials collection today.

I'm sorry I can't provide a more definitive answer in this case, but I hope this information is helpful to you nonetheless. Good luck!!

answered Oct 25 '17
GoodBed Help's gravatar image
GoodBed Help ♦♦
  • 1.3k karma
  • 556 answers
  • 2.4 average
Your answer
toggle preview


Follow this Question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here



Answers and Comments


Asked: Oct 25 '17

Seen: 1,375 times

Last updated: Oct 25 '17

Save this Rebate Code