Find the Right Bed
Comparison
Discounts
Reviews
Mattress 101
Sorry, the email address or password you entered is incorrect.

Forgot password?

Login successful.

Your screen name will look like: Your N from City, ST

VERIFY YOUR ACCOUNT

We just sent an email to

Open the message and click the link to access your account.

  • Expert Reviews
  • Expert Reviews
  • Customer Reviews
  • Popular Online Brands
  • Popular Store Brands
  • All Brands
  • Write a Review
  • Write Review
Close

Box springs

Hello. Could an incorrect or bad box spring cause a new mattress to feel uncomfortable and get a little sore?

Seen 2,095 times Last updated Jun 2020

17 Answers:

Hi there -- Thanks for your question. Yes, this could absolutely happen -- and often does.

Your mattress needs to be supported by a solid, stable foundation -- whether in the form of a box spring, platform, slatted base, or otherwise. So if what you have under the mattress is damaged, worn out, or otherwise inadequate, you will certainly feel this when lying on your mattress, leading to likely discomfort and back pain.

The solid support under the mattress needs to extend all the way to the ground -- including under the center of the mattress on a queen or larger. So the bed frame underneath your box spring is a potential point of failure as well.

Worse yet, even if it's your under-mattress support is to blame at first, the mattress itself can become damaged by using it with inadequate support. So if you determine that your under-mattress support needs to be bolstered, it's best to use your mattress on the floor in the interim.

I hope that's helpful.

10|600 characters needed characters left

Thanks. I have no idea or if is just me or if it has something to do with this bed. Maybe the box spring is messed up since my original mattress was garbage. Only i know how bad it was. Maybe i need time to get used to it or maybe it is messed up somehow. I cannot get a neutral source to diagnose it. But thank you

10|600 characters needed characters left

And one more question. Is there any way to inspect this myself? Without any tools?

10|600 characters needed characters left

Hi there -- To assess the structural integrity of the foundation, I would start by just pulling the mattress off and looking at it to see if it looks completely solid and flat across the top. Once you've ascertained that there is no visible damage or wear, I would then start pushing down on different parts of it to test its strength. In general it really shouldn't budge, and even if you were to have all your weight in one place it shouldn't give more than an inch or so. You could also test this by lying on it without the mattress to make sure it supports your weight without bowing (warning: this won't be very comfortable, so be prepared to be poked or scratched a bit). Lastly, while you're lying on the foundation (with or without the mattress on top), have someone else look underneath the bed to make sure that the underside of the bed isn't bowing at all when there is weight in the center of the mattress.

That probably won't end up being a 100% complete assessment, but I think it should reveal most potential problems.

I hope that's helpful.

10|600 characters needed characters left

Thank you. This is most help i've had. I am more likely to feel the effects of a sagging mattress due to my condition. So who knows. I pressed on it and stuff, seemed ok but i dont know. Are some not made to absorb so much weight maybe? Dont think so or if you can find out. But thank you again.

10|600 characters needed characters left

One more question. I think it's hard for me to sit up from a laying position. Laying on bed to test and feel again. If it's saggy it would be difficult to sit up wouldn't it? Harder for me to move but still. Why it's hard for me to diagnose. Long story, not that old. Thank you

10|600 characters needed characters left

Hi there -- I'm afraid I'm not really able to determine anything conclusive based on that information. Sorry I can't be of more help.

10|600 characters needed characters left

That is ok. One quick question. A new mattress should feel firmer and not more saggy should it though?

10|600 characters needed characters left

Can it feel saggy as it conforms to your body? Does that make sense. Or should it not really?

10|600 characters needed characters left

Hello again. One final question, no more stupid ones. Found out my boxspring was for a gel foam mattress. I amusing it with my new mattress sealy posturpedic memory foam. Are gel foam and memory foam different? Can i use that boxspring? Do you have no idea? Either way. Done so much research, trying to diagnose it myself is very hard. I knew nothing about this until reading lately.

10|600 characters needed characters left

One more thing. My original mattress had pocket coils. Does that make boxspring different. My new mattress has no pocket coils. Does it need a specific boxspring or foundation maybe? Does this even make sense? All i got for now. Thank you again!

10|600 characters needed characters left

Then there's the bed frame to think about.. but i read it's not the frame. Read you can have cheap one and be fine. But i have no idea. I can only hope i gave enough useful information that someone can diagnose and tell me. Please if you could. I do not really expect it though. I'm done.

10|600 characters needed characters left

I put the mattres on the floor, laid down the same. Feels much better. I think that almost must mean it has something to do with the foundation if it doesnt feel as saggy in the middle when on the floor. Can a new mattress be ruined if it has had incorrect foundation for a week?

10|600 characters needed characters left

Hi there -- If the problem is resolved or significantly improved when the mattress is on the floor, then it does sound like there is an issue with the support under the mattress. As for any negative impact that your old box spring might have had on the mattress over the course of just a week's time, it's hard for me to say for sure, but my instinct is that it would be negligible in this case. And if there were any permanent damage to the mattress, I would think you would feel it when testing it on the floor.

I hope that's helpful.

10|600 characters needed characters left

Took me forever to try that out. Even called someone and they told me about the same thing, even said the frame could be at fault. Sure this new mattress is probably somewhat ok but could be a little deformity in there. I requested a brand new everything from my retailer though nonetheless. I may get mad if i need to. They have not helped at all during this dilemma. You have been of help greatly. Thank you.

10|600 characters needed characters left

Without your legitimate answers to my questions it may have been harder to figure this all out. Trying it on the floor was a good idea i think. We will see how this all works out. Thank you!

10|600 characters needed characters left

My pleasure. I’m very glad we could be helpful to you.

10|600 characters needed characters left

Find the Right Mattress

Not sure which bed is best for you? We can assess your needs. Let’s start...What is your preferred sleep position?

“The GoodBed Quiz is by far the best starting point for any mattress shopper.” – Katherine P. in Chicago, IL

Answer a few questions to see the best options for you based on the most advanced mattress matching algorithm on the internet.

Get Expert Answers

Ask your question to the GoodBed experts

Ask a question 

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow this Question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Mattress Research Tools

ADVERTISEMENT