Find the Right Bed
Comparison
Discounts
Reviews
Mattress 101
Sorry, the email address or password you entered is incorrect.

Forgot password?

Login successful.

Your screen name will look like: Your N from City, ST

VERIFY YOUR ACCOUNT

We just sent an email to

Open the message and click the link to access your account.

  • Expert Reviews
  • Expert Reviews
  • Customer Reviews
  • Popular Online Brands
  • Popular Store Brands
  • All Brands
  • Write a Review
  • Write Review
Close

Beautyrest Black vs. Stearns & Foster Cassatt or S&F Rockwell Plush

So I'm stuck picking out a mattress from the selection at a specific retailer to exchange a 2 month old aireloom mattress that had indentations after only 2 months (I am a side sleeper who weights 125 lb) and the only options there that I'd consider are Beautyrest Black vs. Stearns & Foster Cassatt or S&F Rockwell Plush. I prefer the pillow top feels, but in reading it seems like these may be the driver of most indentation issues. Anyone with good insight on quality between these 3 options? I'm finding reports of indentations on both the Black and Cassatt which is the only reason I'd consider the Rockwell and I guess buy a topper. Price is not really a factor since I already bought the Aireloom which was pricier than all the alts and of course I don't get the price difference back - If I go Rockwell, I'd be stuck shelling out extra for a topper somewhere but of course if that's the best course I'd rather just do that than be miserable. appreciate any feedback.

Seen 5,414 times Last updated Sep 2019

One Answer:

what about a rockwell plush pillowtop. supposedly softer than just plush.

10|600 characters needed characters left

Find the Right Mattress

Not sure which bed is best for you? We can assess your needs. Let’s start...What is your preferred sleep position?

“The GoodBed Quiz is by far the best starting point for any mattress shopper.” – Katherine P. in Chicago, IL

Answer a few questions to see the best options for you based on the most advanced mattress matching algorithm on the internet.

Get Expert Answers

Ask your question to the GoodBed experts

Ask a question 

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow this Question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Mattress Research Tools

ADVERTISEMENT