Mattress Reviews

Praise for Noise

“Corsicana Colonial Halifax - 1310 (Corsicana Halifax)”

• The Halifax model from the Corsicana Colonial Collection line by Corsicana

Posted by Don M from Fort Worth, TX on January 22, 2011

Very soft, on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being firm, I would say this mattress is about a 5. Very comfy. It has 1.5 inches of quilt foam on top of 3 inches of the good tempurpedic type foam. you feel yourself squish down in it slowly … →

“Spring Air Back Supporter - 2048 (superb quality)”

• The Spring Air Back Supporter line by Spring Air

Posted by Paul B from Opa Locka, FL on August 27, 2012

I was surprised to read the type of problems the buyers are experiencing. i bought mine, a queen size in 1987, the name on it is" Spring Air, Unipedic 676 Coil, exclusive maker of back supporter mattress" beside sleeping, i often sit on the bed to watch tv and surf … →

“Natural Response - 3075 (Want aches & pains? Get a Natural Response mattress)”

• The Natural Response line by King Koil

Posted by C E from Vancouver, WA on January 23, 2014

Like most shoppers I laid on the bed in the showroom for ~10 minutes and it felt great, but gradually over the past 2 years - more noticeably in the past year our bodies began to sink into the mattress and we are averaged sized people. You would have to … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Yale - 18562 (Excellent bed)”

• The Yale model from the Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) line by Sealy

Posted by Randall from Bothell, WA on August 6, 2015

Firm and supportive yet the plush top is a soft layer and the edge support is an added bonus, it does not crush or sag. I get a great nights sleep with this bed. →

“Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Classic Pontevedra - 6828 (Worst Mattress Ever + Significant Back Pain)”

• The Pontevedra model from the Beautyrest Recharge line by Beautyrest

Posted by AL from Mesa, AZ on January 24, 2015

I have had (2) replacements of this mattress from the American Furniture Warehouse in a period of just a few months. I have had the same issue with each of the mattresses and am having the second one returned in order to purchase another mattress brand all together. I have … →

“BedInABox Natural Silk Elegance Comfort Adjust Gel - 4347 (Very comfortable, great support yet plush at the same time. )”

• The Natural Silk Elegance Comfort Adjust Gel model by BedInABox

Posted by Jesse from Smithtown, NY on December 15, 2014

I've been sleeping on firm spring beds for many years for the back support, this bed is so comfortable - soft and plush yet super supportive as well. Have had the best sleep in years since we got this bed. Seems very well made, and i feel the price is … →

“Bed Boss Visco Heir - 4146 (No comfort like sleeping on cement.)”

• The Visco Heir model by Bed Boss
• Purchased from Necessity Furniture Warehouse (Metairie, LA)

Posted by Derrick from New Orleans, LA on September 21, 2014

Order this bed a month ago from one of there distributor in New Oleans, La. Area ( Necessity Furniture ). Owner had bed in store Visco heir ET and store had a chance to lay on it, and brought wife back so that she had a change to try it … →

“Serta iComfort Genius - 4105 (My husband and I are heavy, the middle of the mattress fe...)”

• The Genius model from the Serta iComfort (Pre-2017) line by Serta
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Robin W from Carleton, MI on September 18, 2014

My husband and I are heavy, the middle of the mattress feels sunk in. I roll towards my husband when sleeping. The mattress does not hold it's form for long in the middle. I wake up with back aches. →

“Saatva Classic 14.5" Luxury Firm - 7821 (Best Decision Ever)”

• The Saatva Classic Luxury Firm 14.5" model by Saatva

Posted by Carla from Gonzales, LA on February 12, 2015

I have been looking for the last couple of years for a mattress. I was very nervous about making a decision because you really can't tell if you are going to like something by laying on it for 3 minutes in a store. And, very nervous about buying a mattress … →

“Saatva Classic 11.5" Firm - 14970 (Best mattress ever.)”

• The Saatva Classic Firm 11.5" model by Saatva

Posted by Ramon from Brandon, FL on June 14, 2015

The best mattress i bought in my life, King Size Firm Delivery in June 9, 2015 and in a week no more back pain Just try it and you wiil sleep overall the clouds. Thanks you SAATVA. →

“Stearns & Foster Signature - 8714 (Great Mattress, Great Store)”

• The Stearns & Foster Signature line by Stearns & Foster
• Purchased from Mattress King

Posted by Glenn from Muskogee, OK on February 26, 2015

Earl was very helpful in the store and not at all pushy. He is knowledgeable and made the shopping and buying experience great. I highly recommend Mattress King in Muskogee and love this Stearns and Foster Mattress! →

“Corsicana - 122895 (Lumpy creaky, side of bed came out made it feel like a slide)”

• The Corsicana brand

Posted by David from Kansas City, MO on March 3, 2017

This bed is worthless cannot sleep very uncomfortable. →

“Saatva Classic 14.5" Luxury Firm - 9278 (This is the best matress you can buy!)”

• The Saatva Classic Luxury Firm 14.5" model by Saatva

Posted by Kimberly from Lincoln, NE on March 8, 2015

3/8/15-this is my updated review of our Saatva mattress: Its now been over a year and my husband and I truly love this mattress. It is exactly the same as when we bought it! No impressions, no breaking down of the edges, no loss of firmness, and really comfortable! Neither … →

“Simmons BeautySleep Prospect Park Plush - 11105 (got it to replace grand rapids plush )”

• The Prospect Park Plush model from the Simmons BeautySleep (Pre-2017) line by Beautyrest

Posted by Carlee on April 6, 2015

Still too firm... and took forever to get this one after complaining about the grand rapids one... to the salesman that I couldn't sleep at all yhe first three nights... expressed my concerns about it being the wrong one and they postponed twice to getting me this once which is … →

“BedInABox PacBamboo Gel - 12352 (Everything was easy to setup)”

• The PacBamboo Gel model by BedInABox

Posted by Tony from Fairfax, VA on April 28, 2015

I purchased the full bed package, which included the frame, the recommended wooden mattress support, and the mattress. The mattress was a bit heavy to carry by myself, but I was able to manage it. The frame and the mattress support were easier to carry up stairs. The frame's instructions … →

“Chattam & Wells - 13615 (Chattam & Wells the BEST bed ever!!)”

• The Chattam & Wells line by Spring Air

Posted by Wendy from Lafayette, CA on May 22, 2015

When we bought our Chattam & Wells bed nearly 20 years ago, I was worried we had spent too much on our mattress. But, it lasts forever: this mattress is so well made, I fear they will go out of business, because nobody will have to buy new mattresses. Warning: … →

“Pure LatexBliss Nature - 22646 (I LOVE THIS BED!!)”

• The Nature model from the Pure LatexBliss Natural Latex Collection line by Pure Talalay Bliss
• Purchased from John Paras Furniture

Posted by Mary from Green River, WY on September 18, 2015

I can't say it enough - I love this bed! It's by far the best bed we have EVER owned. It's comfortable the second you lie down, and there's very little motion transfer so if one of us gets up in the middle of the night we aren't waking the … →

“Sealy Posturepedic Optimum Elation - 292409 (Needs more support)”

• The Elation model from the Sealy Posturepedic Optimum line by Sealy

Posted by Jessica from Flowery Branch, GA on July 10, 2018

Too saggy, sink in too much. →

“Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid Medium (2015-2020) - 260483 (Best Mattress)”

• The Alexander Signature Hybrid Medium (2015-2020) model from the Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid (2015-2020) line by Nest Bedding

Posted by Eliza T from Chicago, IL on April 4, 2018

I tried a Kluft mattress in a store, and this mattress feels very similar at a fraction of the price. Good support, but with a soft memory foam top that makes you feel like you're floating on a cloud when you lie down. And it is very quiet, no creaking … →

“Serta Perfect Sleeper (Pre-2019) - 137427 (Great for a year, lumpy after that)”

• The Serta Perfect Sleeper (Pre-2019) line by Serta

Posted by Peter from Vancouver, BC on April 24, 2017

I have owned this mattress for over three years; my wife and I are height weight proportional and in good shape. Took at least 6 months to break in and then seemed like a great bed. Unfortunately after that it continued to break in more and developed indentations and a … →

“Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid Medium (2015-2020) - 267713 (Comfort I never thought I could Afford)”

• The Alexander Signature Hybrid Medium (2015-2020) model from the Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid (2015-2020) line by Nest Bedding

Posted by Jacob P on April 23, 2018

I always figured I would would end up shelling out thousands of dollars for a Tempur-Pedic of some sort to end my bedtime woes. Did some research on "internet mattresses" to compare the pros and cons, maybe save some money, and happened upon Nest bedding and the Alexander hybrid matterss. … →

“Primo Dream - 35519 (Very good bed )”

• The Primo Dream line by Primo

Posted by Rebecca from Gander, NL on January 3, 2016

I definitely recommend this mattress. It feels like you're sleeping on a cloud. It's definitely a big upgrade from my last bed. You can flip this mattress depending on your preferences, one side is firmer then the other. →

“Nature's Rest - 27351 (Comfortable)”

• The Nature's Rest brand

Posted by Heather from Lawrence, KS on November 11, 2015

Very comfortable, pillow top is too soft so we flip it over and sleep on the 'back'. This thing is a beast to move. Seriously, its like 200 pounds of no-bone floppyness. I bought it in March 2003, and in Fall 2015, it is starting to show its age. The … →

“WinkBed Soft (2017-2021) - 370910 (A Dream)”

• The Soft (2017-2021) model by WinkBed

Posted by Jason B from Natick, MA on April 27, 2019

I did a lot of online research to replace my very old Stearns and Foster mattress. I thought I wanted to try the memory foam mattresses that come in a box due to the low price point and good reviews. My research steered me toward a more traditional mattress for … →

“Dormia - 375205 (Bad long term investment)”

• The Dormia brand

Posted by Jen from Middletown, NY on May 18, 2019

I'm glad that these mattresses are no longer available to purchase. It was great at first, however about a year in started to develop body impressions, which have continued to degrade since. All four over $3,000! The company touted a 30 year warranty, however there is no way to claim … →

“Real Bed - 432035 (Wonderful, quality, Medium Firm, ( and my wife loves it))”

• The Real Bed brand

Posted by Jim from Delaware, OH on February 9, 2020

This is our third Mattress in five years. Trying to find the one that would work for us both. It is PERFECT !! It is soft enough that my wife loves it and firm enough for me. It has great support but is not springy. It is quiet, and if … →

Complaints for Noise

“Serta Perfect Sleeper (Pre-2019) - 1030 (Can't complain)”

• The Serta Perfect Sleeper (Pre-2019) line by Serta

Posted by Mark L from Chappaqua, NY on December 9, 2009

Slept on this mattress for years without really thinking much about it -- which is basically all I require from a mattress. →

“Corsicana - 2314 (Screaming loud on the edges)”

• The Corsicana brand

Posted by Mary C from Mount Juliet, TN on December 14, 2012

I've had many differenet mattresses in the past but I can honestly say that I've never had one like this. After 2 months the sides of the mattress made so much noise getting in and out of the bed that if I get up in the middle of the night, … →

“Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image - 1301 (Dreamy latex mattress)”

• The Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image line by Carolina Mattress Guild
• Purchased from Mattress Xpress

Posted by Philip L from Fort Lauderdale, FL on January 16, 2011

I bought a Nature's Image natural latex mattress in March. From the first night, I have noticed that I fall asleep faster. In fact, I've been sleeping better, and I don't wake up as much during the night. I have had lower back problems in the past, and I used … →

“Southerland - 1537 (Worst Mattress Ever!)”

• The Southerland brand

Posted by Steve C from Cleveland, OH on July 1, 2011

The poorest constructed mattress I have ever had the misfortune of owning. The mattress sunk in over 3 inches in less than a month. My wife and I both had horrible back and leg pain from sleeping on this horrible pos. The box spring/foundation also squeeked like crazy and sagged. … →

“Corsicana - 2001 (Garbage)”

• The Corsicana brand
• Purchased from Scholet Furniture (Oneonta, NY)

Posted by Anonymous from Oneonta, NY on July 30, 2012

I assumed this was the absolute cheapest one they make because you can't flip it. I may be right that it was the cheapest one (my husband bought it and he's no longer with us) but I guess the mattress industry "makes them that way now "so that they don't … →

“Corsicana - 2263 (squeaky and sags on the side when you sit on the mattress)”

• The Corsicana brand

Posted by Imogene P from Macon, GA on November 25, 2012

Will never buy any product made by this company. It squeaks from the time you get in the bed until the time you get out. →

“Therapedic - 2127 (Worst bed ever)”

• The Therapedic brand
• Purchased from Conn's (Oklahoma City, OK)

Posted by Abbey W from Oklahoma City, OK on September 29, 2012

This is the worst mattress I have ever owned. Bought it new from Conn's in June 2011 (15 months ago) and the mattress is already collapsing/caving in. The box spring squeaks and creaks every time you move on the bed. It is so loud I can hear my husband getting … →

“Restonic Comfort Master Stratus Plush - 96877 (Would be perfect if didn't wear so quickly.)”

• The Comfort Master Stratus Plush model from the Restonic Comfort Master line by Restonic

Posted by Tricia from Wellsboro, PA on December 2, 2016

We purchase this bed 14 months ago. At first it felt like we were sleeping in a pillow of clouds. This was our first plush, previous firm mattresses lasted well for us but didn't seem to help with back and body pain, so we chose to try a plush/pillow top … →

“Carolina Mattress Guild Tapestry - 2996 (Noisy in San Marcos, December 13, 2013)”

• The Tapestry model by Carolina Mattress Guild
• Purchased from Rooms To Go

Posted by Barbara M from San Marcos, TX on December 13, 2013

My husband and I moved to San Marcos in June of 2013 and needed new mattresses...opted for Therapedic...very comfortable and we did not disturb each other when we got up during the night. In September I broke out in hives-never been allergic to anything-after much talking and research my husband … →

“Pure LatexBliss Pamper - 3139 (Very Squeaky Mattress Set!!)”

• The Pamper model from the Pure LatexBliss Natural Latex Collection line by Pure Talalay Bliss

Posted by R W from Beverly Hills, CA on March 2, 2014

I purchased a queen Pure LatexBliss set from a local store and unfortunately my Pure LatexBliss mattress set squeaks very loudly waking me up at night! It squeaked the very first moment when I laid on it, as well as when I moved around at night causing me to wake … →

“Stewart & Hamilton - 3548 (toss and turn turmoil)”

• The Stewart & Hamilton brand

Posted by Kathryn from Mc Comb, OH on June 5, 2014

First off, this is the noisiest bed, why would you put some kind of cardboard on top of box spring? We tried out at store, seemed so comfortable, not the same when we got home. Store said we had guarantee, went to use the guarantee, they told us there was … →

“Select Comfort Sleep Number 7000 Bed - 3602 (Squeaky!!)”

• The Sleep Number 7000 Bed model by Sleep Number

Posted by Mary-Allegra F from San Diego, CA on July 9, 2014

We purchased a sleep number bed over 9 years ago and loved it! The , a year or so ago, we found mold inside. Apparently, there was a recall. We were never informed. The company sent out a brand new bed (after our newborn co-slept with us for nearly 3 … →

“Restonic ComfortCare - 3933 (Sore Back)”

• The Restonic ComfortCare line by Restonic
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Keith T from Warren, MI on August 21, 2014

Bed lack Back support,way to soft to be a firm mattress,Sad thing is I won this mattress in the Dream Team Contest and was really excited,So I threw my old bed out (Beauty Rest) anticipating this was going to be so much better but to my surprise its not.I know … →

“Serta - 4019 (Not so great)”

• The Serta brand
• Purchased from Gardner White Furniture

Posted by Lawrence L from Clinton Township, MI on September 16, 2014

At first it was fine, but over time it seems to degrade in quality. Obviously, it's not worth the $800 I spent on it. Could have gotten something a lot nicer for cheaper. Sadly disappointing. →

“Zenhaven Luxury Plush - 104811 (box platform squeaks like old rocker will try to get replace)”

• The Zenhaven (Soft Side) model by Zenhaven
• Purchased from Zenhaven

Posted by Terry P from Roswell, GA on January 6, 2017

If can get the box spring replace, and if mattress continues the way it has the first 4 or 5 Months, we will have chosen the right mattress →

“Hampton and Rhodes Premont 14" Luxury Pillow Top - 4369 (Horrible horrible horrible)”

• The Premont 14" Luxury Pillow Top model by Hampton & Rhodes
• Purchased from Mattress Firm (Henderson, NV)

Posted by Michelle from Henderson, NV on December 18, 2014

This is the worst bed I have ever slept on in my life. It's horrifying to sleep feeling like you will fall off the bed especially when you are 9 months pregnant. My entire pregnancy was full of pain due to this horrible excuse for a bed. It has huge … →

“Hampton and Rhodes 11" Luxury Pillow Top - 5623 (Loud Mattress)”

• The 11" Luxury Pillow Top model by Hampton & Rhodes
• Purchased from Mattress Firm

Posted by Zina from Sarasota, FL on January 6, 2015

The squeaking wakes my husband I up all during the nigHt →

“Beautyrest Dreamwell - 6240 (HORRIBLE BED)”

• The Dreamwell model by Beautyrest

Posted by Debora from West Point, VA on January 15, 2015

My first Simmons Beautyrest Dreamwell Cliff Haven Plush Pillow Top was replaced after just 3 months. This is the second mattress I've had for about 1 year and today has been inspected. Shows obvious 2 inch sink in middle. Back and neck problems have now escalated due to this poorly … →

“iSleep Sleep Adjustment Bed - 10770 (Terrible bed. Did not honor refund either.)”

• The Sleep Adjustment Bed model by iSleep

Posted by Kari from Rock Springs, WY on March 31, 2015

Called Isleep because my chiropractor claimed it was a great bed. Talked with the salesman, Lynn, about the bed for a bit and asked if it came with a metal frame so we wouldn't have to go buy a new one, Lynn stated it did. Received bed, metal frame was … →

“Sleep Number Innovation i8 bed - 18350 (Not exactly what they claim it to be.)”

• The i8 bed model from the Sleep Number Innovation Series line by Sleep Number

Posted by John on August 3, 2015

Do you like experimenting with your sleep? Do you like paying large sums of money for add ons that other products can provide for free? Do you like that half inflated air mattress, going to fall out of the bed, watch your partner bounce when you roll over feeling? This … →

“Sleep Number Personal Preference - 20233 (This is the worst bed I've ever owned! From the beginnin...)”

• The Sleep Number Personal Preference line by Sleep Number

Posted by Dorjean from Chesterfield, MO on August 24, 2015

This is the worst bed I've ever owned! From the beginning, the mattress couldn't hold air on one side of the bed, always had to refill it daily. Customer service was no help with the problem, they said to place a cap on that side of the bed so that … →

“Corsicana Brigham Medici Eurotop - 20451 (Worst bed I've ever owned)”

• The Medici Eurotop model from the Corsicana Brigham Collection line by Corsicana

Posted by Sarah from Belle Plaine, MN on August 26, 2015

The sides collapsed in less than a year. The bed looks like a hammock and I wake up every day in horrible pain. The bed squeaks so loud with the slightest movement. We are not heavy people either (135 & 160). Biggest waste of money we ever spent. →

“Symbol - 19530 (Noisy)”

• The Symbol brand

Posted by Marilyn from Columbus, NE on August 17, 2015

From the beginning this mattress makes noise when you get in and out of bed, creaking and groaning. →

“Simmons Beautyrest Recharge World Class Sonora Extra Firm - 181107 (I bought this matttess in march 2015. Within the 1st few ...)”

• The Sonora Extra Firm model from the Beautyrest Recharge line by Beautyrest
• Purchased from Macy's

Posted by Tom from Granite City, IL on September 2, 2017

I bought this matttess in march 2015. Within the 1st few months I heard and felt springs either shifting or breaking. After about a year I was sleeping in a hole. After 2 years it was giving me severe lower back and shoulder pain, numbness down my arm. I am … →

“BedInABox Natural Silk Elegance Gel - 317306 (Loss of support after 4 years)”

• The Natural Silk Elegance Gel model by BedInABox

Posted by Heidi from Colchester, CT on October 1, 2018

For the first year of owning the mattress, it felt okay. At first it felt a bit too fir, then softened over time. Now after four years, it squeaks loudly with the slightest movement, has no more support, and has sunken on the sides. I wake up with bad pain … →

“Hampton & Rhodes HR400 Cushion Firm - 151069 (This mattress squeeks)”

• The HR400 Cushion Firm model by Hampton & Rhodes

Posted by Richard from Charlotte, MI on June 10, 2017

This mattress is very noisy, mostly around the outside edges. It is very annoying.The mattress has been replaced once, but the replacement mattress is worse than the first one. I don't like the inconvenience of dealing with the mattress replacement. Also, I shouldn't have to keep paying the delivery charge. →

“White Dove - 179602 (We returned the first mattress because it bowed (high in ...)”

• The White Dove brand

Posted by Dagmar from Cleveland, OH on August 29, 2017

We returned the first mattress because it bowed (high in the middle, low on the sides). We received a new mattress and this one is too soft and it squeaks every time you sit or lay on it. The edges of the mattress are too soft and still bow but … →

“Ikea Sultan Hanestad - 191621 (Mattress does not last)”

• The Sultan Hanestad model by IKEA

Posted by Madeleyne from San Diego, CA on October 1, 2017

I got this mattress about 2 years ago. When I first got it it was great, now it's so crappy, I can feel the springs, and sometimes I hear like stuff is breaking inside. The mattress feels so lumpy now (when I first got it it had some firmness to … →

“Carolina Mattress Guild ReFreshing Escapes - 49385 (Creaky, mushy, sinks in the middle)”

• The Carolina Mattress Guild ReFreshing Escapes line by Carolina Mattress Guild

Posted by Delores from Philadelphia, PA on March 13, 2016

I paid too much money for a mattress that creaks, is mushy, lumpy and just all out bad. A warranty would have only been money wasted. →

“Sleep Number Performance p6 bed - 125180 (No support and base off gasses like crazy.)”

• The p6 bed model from the Sleep Number Performance Series line by Sleep Number

Posted by Jenn from Danville, CA on March 10, 2017

No one will tell me what the base is made of, it's some sotr of polymer, don't know if it uses recycled materials, but it smells bad. Additionally, every time the bed expels air, it also smells bad and is noisy. The bed does not offer any support for my … →

“Sterling & Thomas - 194735 (I was satisfied until almost a year and it started creaki...)”

• The Sterling & Thomas line by American Bedding

Posted by Marilyn from Groveton, NH on October 10, 2017

I was satisfied until almost a year and it started creaking,turned the box spring around and the mattress and still did not stop it Then i looked at the box spring again and found it has cardboard in it and that's what's squeaking.Never had a box spring built so cheap!! … →

“Corsicana Eloquence Rufino Pillowtop - 180381 (Awful, uncomfortable, noisy bed)”

• The Rufino Pillowtop model from the Corsicana Eloquence Collection line by Corsicana

Posted by Kelly from San Marcos, CA on August 31, 2017

Very disappointed. Owned the bed for 20 months and now going back to my old bed. I need sleep. Feels like you are sleeping on concrete and the bed is noisy as if there is straw in it. Worse bed i have ever slept on. Stop making it! →

“Hampton & Rhodes Quail Creek Ultra Plush Pillowtop - 374442 (The sales person at Mattress Firm Oakbrook, Ill... made i...)”

• The Quail Creek Ultra Plush Pillowtop model from the Hampton & Rhodes line by Hampton & Rhodes

Posted by Shari from Maywood, IL on May 14, 2019

The sales person at Mattress Firm Oakbrook, Ill... made it sound like we were getting a steal by purchasing at Hampton & Rhodes mattress (knowing they were closing down soon). I purchased the mattress Feb 2018 and I feel like I roll to the middle every night..The mattress squeaks when … →

“Corsicana Harmony Canberra Firm - 123167 (Very Noisy)”

• The Canberra Firm model from the Corsicana Harmony Collection line by Corsicana

Posted by William from Tallahassee, FL on March 4, 2017

I bought a new bed and mattress set for my grandson to use while he was visiting my home. He used it for about four months before moving on to another location. He never made any comments about the mattress and/or foundation making a horrible squeaking noise when getting into … →

“Hampton & Rhodes HR100 Firm - 356824 (Hard as a Rock with no support)”

• The HR100 Firm model by Hampton & Rhodes

Posted by Erik from Fort Lauderdale, FL on February 22, 2019

I bought this mattress for cost purposes. As soon as the guys delivered it, i immediately knew it wasn't at all worth the money. I looked at my warranty from Mattress Firm and they wanted $149.00 delivery fee to return it. That's almost the cost of the mattress. I got … →

“Zenhaven - 326186 (Excellent Mattress, Horrible Delivery Experience)”

• The Zenhaven brand

Posted by Kelly from Cicero, NY on November 4, 2018

The mattress is excellent in terms of how it feels. It will supposedly have a 20-year life. I'm not so sure about that, but the company stands behind their claim, so I figured it was worth the investment. My problem with this whole experience was in the delivery. The first … →

“Jonathan Stevens Regent - 185154 (Nightmares)”

• The Jonathan Stevens Regent line by Jonathan Stevens

Posted by Laura from Grand Rapids, MI on September 10, 2017

I went to Johnathan Stevens believing they were a reputable company located in Grand Rapids, MI. I went into the store on 28th St at least 3xs before purchasing the mattress to lay on it and speak to the sales person. I explained my situation with other mattresses (not good), … →

“Purple Original - 340096 (move along)”

• The Purple Original model by Purple

Posted by Chad from Madison, WI on December 28, 2018

I have owned the purple mattress for a little over a year. It is permanently swayed, both on my side (210 lbs.) and my wife's side (110 lbs.). There are limited options for rotating this mattress, so there's no way to even it out. We also purchased the purple bed … →

“Corsicana Brigham Simplicity Pillowtop - 356864 (side breakdown!!)”

• The Simplicity Pillowtop model from the Corsicana Brigham Collection line by Corsicana

Posted by vicki from Ozark, AR on February 22, 2019

I had a Sealy set for over 25 yrs and it was awesome. gave it to my daughter, who used it 3 more yrs. you cannot beat that! But, this Corsicana Simplicity pillow top is 3 yrs old, barely, and it is ready for the dump!! The sides are broken … →

“Park Place 75th Anniversary - 352345 (Noisy and sunken in)”

• The Park Place line by Park Place

Posted by Randy from China Grove, NC on February 9, 2019

We had this Holiday mattress to give us trouble from the start. The fountain was very noisy after only a few days and the mattress is sagging from where we lay more than our old mattress did after we had it for more than 10 years. Will never buy another … →

“Corsicana - 143651 (loud)”

• The Corsicana brand

Posted by ruth from Festus, MO on May 18, 2017

the worst bedding I have ever purchased. box springs make a very loud noise everytime you move. have emailed the company, but no response. →

“Symbol - 170733 (Worst Mattress Ever!!!)”

• The Symbol brand

Posted by Joey from Clinton, WI on August 7, 2017

It is less than 2 years old, and feels like its 20!!! Contacted the manufacturer after approximately 1 year, and they would do nothing about it. Even sent them photos. It creaks so loud it wakes us up, even with the slightest movement. We immediately roll to the middle upon … →

“Stewart & Hamilton - 239340 (Worst mattress I have ever slept on)”

• The Stewart & Hamilton brand

Posted by Tracey from Hixson, TN on February 12, 2018

I purchased a Perfect Care 3000 queen sized mattress from American Freight last year. To say I am disappointed in the mattress would be an understatement. Within two months the mattress began sagging. The dip in the center of the mattress is now very significant. The comfort level is severely … →

“MLily Harmony - 247205 (Every pressure point hurts.)”

• The Harmony model by MLILY

Posted by Dianne from Little Elm, TX on February 28, 2018

At first our Mlily Harmony was comfortable. However it quickly lost support in the areas where my husband and I sleep. We tried rotating the mattress, which worked the first time. So we had about a year of comfort (6 months one way and 6 months the second way) before … →

“Continental Sleep - 198133 (Good mattress - horrible box spring)”

• The Continental Sleep brand

Posted by Stacey from Semmes, AL on October 21, 2017

After 4 months, the box spring had turned into the loudest I've ever heard! Gets worse with every roll, turn, or sit up. →

“Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Allie Firm Tight Top - 213400 (I suffer from shoulder pain sisnce I have this mattress)”

• The Allie Firm Tight Top model from the Beautyrest Recharge line by Beautyrest

Posted by Heidi from Atlanta, GA on December 1, 2017

I wanted to buy a firm mattress with a pillowtop for support, and plush comfort. This bed is hard like a rock. It also makes noises when I turn. Feels and sounds like the pillowtop filled with straw. I purchased this mattress 2 years ago because of the pocketed coil … →

“American Sleep - 198702 (Started off good but 3 yrs in, this mattress is uncomfortab)”

• The American Sleep brand

Posted by Monicia from Sandusky, OH on October 22, 2017

3 yrs in, we are experiencing dips in the mattress. Very loud squeaks when sitting or laying down. Not happy at all with the product and store had gone out of business. A mattress should last more than 4-5 years. →

“Sealy BackSaver Rain Song Plush - 231402 (Not as promised on display)”

• The Rain Song Plush model from the Sealy BackSaver line by Sealy

Posted by Matt from Abingdon, VA on January 24, 2018

Expected good support lasting several years. Was seemingly fine when delivered but soon began to sink where each of us sleep. Kingsize..can't flip, only turn. Middle stays same, feels like going uphill to reach spouse side. Back aches, neck gets kinks often, and it now creeks with every move. We … →

“WinkBed Luxury Firm (2016-2021) - 371006 (Lousy box spring system.)”

• The Luxury Firm (2016-2021) model by WinkBed

Posted by RICHARD P on April 27, 2019

I feel this mattresses perceived shortcomings arise from the box spring system more than the mattress itself. Rather an important component to rating the mattress yet your survey gives it ZERO consideration. I have had to fiddle with and readjust the box spring set (king) numerous times. The main problem … →

“Sierra Sleep - 271364 (This is the worse mattress I've hard in my 77 yrs. Of mat...)”

• The Sierra Sleep line by Ashley Sleep

Posted by Sharon from Rialto, CA on May 5, 2018

This is the worse mattress I've hard in my 77 yrs. Of mattress buying. I be had it for over 1 1/2 yr. It makes the most horrible noises from day one, I had my young grandchildren sit on different places on it & it even made noises with their … →

“Beautyrest - 281630 (BeautyRest my Azz)”

• The Beautyrest brand

Posted by Bill from Comox, BC on June 4, 2018

It's our second Simmons in less than 4 years. The first needed replacing after 2 years. This one has been slightly less than 2 years and sidewalls are crumbling and there's deep grooves on one side (same problem as the first one) and it also squeaks. Terrible mattresses! →

“Gold Bond Sacro Support Buckingham Ultra Firm - 377474 (Creaky and saggy after a few months)”

• The Buckingham Ultra Firm model from the Gold Bond Sacro Support line by Gold Bond

Posted by Kate from Belfast, ME on May 27, 2019

Very disappointed with this mattress. Began creaking like an old bed after 1 month! The sides have lost support and sink when you sit on the bed. You can feel the springs through the sides. I have flipped and turned the mattress as instructed. I weigh 160 lbs and the … →

“Symbol - 283749 (Wears out fast)”

• The Symbol brand

Posted by Dennis from Stahlstown, PA on June 12, 2018

This bed felt good at first but quickly deteriorated, it offers no support and is very noisy. I would never buy another one. →

“Simmons Beautyrest Phenom Crossover Firm - 291602 (This Bed appears to give out after 2 years of use...)”

• The Crossover Firm model from the Beautyrest Phenom line by Beautyrest

Posted by mary from Paw Paw, IL on July 8, 2018

We bought this bed from Sleepy's (now Mattress Firm) May of 2016. We needed a new bed that was going to work better for both of us. Our Adjustable Air bed was just not working for us, and we decided to finally go to a mattress store. We moved into … →

“Original Mattress Factory Orthopedic Ultra Plush - 298449 (Old School Junk)”

• The Orthopedic Ultra Plush model by Original Mattress Factory

Posted by Carmine from Westerville, OH on July 31, 2018

We bought 2 Twin XL's for our King Size Bed: After one night my wife and I woke up in pain and tired from the lack of quality sleep. Severe back pain. constantly waking all light long. Poorly made, poor design, lifting handle broke on the first use, the mattress … →

“Sealy Comfort Series Gel Memory Foam Boca Breeze - 303455 (Sleeping apart)”

• The Boca Breeze model from the Sealy Brand line by Sealy

Posted by Gail from Midland, TX on August 17, 2018

Sealy usef to be a good brand. Is it just this model? Between the creaking and not getting comfortable I spend more time sleeping apart from my spouse than with him. I finally decided I had to check into the warranty to see if there was anything that could be … →

“Corsicana - 303436 (indentations on the mattress. pitches to edge. squeaky.)”

• The Corsicana brand

Posted by Bobbie from Las Vegas, NV on August 17, 2018

at first it was fine. then, when i or hubby got up, it started making noises - squeaky. then, i noticed that it would pitch us toward the edge of the bed and if we tried to turn over, it was almost impossible. my hip pain has gotten way worse … →

“Corsicana Eloquence - 484784 (Sleeping on a sagging pile of branches)”

• The Corsicana Eloquence line by Corsicana

Posted by Christine from Camden, TN on September 26, 2020

We had only had this mattress for 6 months when it sagged on both sides. The creaking is very loud, I think it's coming from the box spring. It sounds like wood on wood grinding if that helps you understand the sound. I would NEVER buy one again, let alone … →

“Kingsdown Emerald Crown Duke Cushion Firm - 498275 (What a horrible experience)”

• The Emerald Crown Duke Cushion Firm model by Kingsdown

Posted by Jim from New York, NY on December 5, 2020

My inlaws had this mattress in their guest room and we had thought it was comfortable. When it was time to get a new mattress they surprised us with the Kingsdown Emerald Crown Duke in a king size. We have been sleeping in it for about two months and it … →

“DreamCloud Premier Rest (2021-2022) - 555038 (I was so excited about this mattress at first. I bought i...)”

• The DreamCloud Premier Rest (2021-2022) model by DreamCloud

Posted by Leslie from Durham, NC on November 18, 2021

I was so excited about this mattress at first. I bought it in July of 2021. By October, it was squeaking and sagging on the edge. Warranty was relatively easy and they sent a replacement. The new mattress sags in the middle and is also squeaky. I am getting my … →

“Sealy Aragon Select Plush Euro Top - 598962 (Old reliable, 9 years old.)”

• The Aragon Select Plush Euro Top model by Sealy

Posted by Alexandria from San Jacinto, CA on December 18, 2022

Despite owning for 9 years it works excellently. It’s very temperature controlled, I never get toasty while sleeping on it. It’s a little squeaky when you get on/off or make major movements, it’s not from age though, it’s always been like this. Never had back pain, never woke up in … →

“Serenity Sleep - 615357 (Most creaky mattress ever! Miserable!)”

• The Serenity Sleep brand

Posted by William from Crossville, TN on May 29, 2023

From day one this mattress has creaked and groaned with every move. I am completely unhappy with it. →

“Beautyrest Charlotte Pillowtop - 619099 (Mattress sucks)”

• The Charlotte Pillowtop model by Beautyrest

Posted by Harriet from Racine, WI on July 10, 2023

I purchased this mattress from Mattress Firm. I contacted them and they said I had a warranty on it. I did what they asked me to do and now I still have no resolution. The edge of the mattress has no support when you sit down. I purchased an adjustable … →

“Sleepy's Hush 10" Plush - 626392 (Worst Mattress of All Time)”

• The Hush 10" Plush model by Sleepys

Posted by Michael from Las Vegas, NV on October 3, 2023

This was the worst mattress I’ve ever had. Period. I had this mattress for 5 years and since the day it was delivered it’s been absolutely terrible. Stiff, squeaky, zero support. This mattress literally has nothing good about it. Finally getting rid if it and never buying a Sleepy’s ever … →