Carolina Mattress Guild
Mattress Ratings & Reviews

Carolina Mattress Guild logo
85/100
Very Good
Back Support
64
Pressure Relief
68
Sleep Quality
68
Stays "Cool"
74
Value
57
Warranty Service
N/A
Average Lifespan
8.3 Years

Not sure this product is right for you?

Take the

GoodBed Match Quiz
Back Support
64
Pressure Relief
68
Sleep Quality
68
Stays "Cool"
74
Value
57
Warranty Service
N/A
Average Lifespan
8.3 Years

Not sure this product is right for you?

Take the

GoodBed Match Quiz
FILTER
517 total ratings, 57 with reviews
Male
Elizabeth LPhiladelphia, PA
Review left on Mar 8, 2013

Cardboard 'W'

I purchased this mattress less than 6 months ago and it feels like cardboard. Being newly married, first thing on the list was to purchase a new mattress, and we went to test out the models at Sleepy's. We ended up loving the Carolina Radiant Pillowtop, but were reluctant to spend the money on a brand that we had never heard of, but went ahead and got it. Sure enough, got the new bed delivered, and it felt like a totally different bed that what we had tried. 2 weeks in, and there were very noticeable dips where I lay and my husband lays, and I only weigh 100 lbs. I try to sleep in the middle of the bed to make it wear evenly, but literally roll down into my dip. Read online reviews and the manufacturer keeps speaking about the 'settling-in' period, so we tried to stick it out. Now approaching 6 months in we are sleeping in a hard 'W'. Making the bed makes me irate when I have to see the shape of the bed we just purchased- it is even noticeable through the down comforter, duvet and 2 blankets! If the bed needs to break in, why is the floor model in perfect condition? Very angry because we thought we purchased the mattress that suited us best. The garbage product that arrived was absolutely not what we paid for.
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image Radiant Pillowtop
Official Response
Hi Elizabeth -- the person that posted on March 22nd is correct -- you need to contact Sleepy's and have them come look at your mattress to see if you could qualify for an exchange or a warranty claim. This is not normal and should not ever happen. You asked why showroom beds might feel different than a bed that arrives at your door -- the main reason is because people lay, jump, sit, roll, etc. on them on a daily basis. They are the best way for you to be able to test the mattress, but obviously not a fool-proof way to see what the mattress will be like when it's in your bedroom. We're so sorry to hear that you've had a bad experience with your Radiant, I hope that Sleepy's can make it right for you. And please also never be content with a mattress (whether it is our or someone else's) that does not feel right to you, or performs in a way that was not what you reasonably expected -- this is why stores offer comfort guarantees and manufacturers offer warranties.
0
See full review+ 2 comments

Male
Lara NNew York, NY
Review left on Feb 26, 2013

Disastisfied with Carolina Firm Radiant Queen Mattress

After 1 month the bed is sinking in the area that I regularly sleep. Sleepys came and set up the bed frame, box spring and mattress and after just 4 weeks the mattress is already losing firmness and shape and sinking. At 120 lbs. I am not a large or heavy person I am greatly disappointed with the quality and more so with Sleepy's lack of customer support. They have passed my case onto a third party called Mattress Marshals to come and do an inspection. I am still waiting for them to call me to set the appointment and while I wait I continue to have night after night of uncomfortable rest and aches and pains. I would be more satisfied is Sleepys would be willing to replace the mattress and let me try another one in case this is a lemon but so far they continue to hang up on my calls to customer service and make it very difficult to find any resolution to this problem.
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image Radiant Firm
Official Response
We're so sorry to hear about these issues with the Radiant mattresses. Just so everyone knows, the standard for warrantable impression depth on these models is 1.5" -- if they are requesting that they wait til you have a 2" impression, please send an email to info [at] carolinamattressguild [dot] com explaining your situation so that we can help remedy it and get you the support that you need.
0
See full review+ 22 comments

Male
Laurel DReynoldsburg, OH
Review left on Feb 24, 2013

super comfy, but

This was my first bed purchase, aside from a futon as a teenager, and the bed my ex already had [which was TOO HARD. I hated it] So I was very excited to get my first bed, and I knew I wanted it to be soft, and amazing. I have pretty much hit the nail on the head with this one. The Energy Plush is very comfortable and doesn't leave me sore in the morning like firmer beds can. My only issue with this [and this may be my fault since I've never owned a bed like this before] is from sitting on the side of my bed to put my shoes on each morning, the mattress has sort of dented there. I hate the way that looks, had I known it was so fragile I never would have done it! but lesson learned I guess. All in all, great bed but DONT sit on the edge on a regular basis
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild Natural Living Energy Plush
Official Response
Hi Laurel! We're glad to hear that the comfort level of the Energy is just right for you! It can be really difficult to pick out a mattress (especially the first time!) so it's great that you were able to find your comfort preference and that it has lived up to your expectations. Speaking to your sagging edge issue, that can happen to a certain extent over time and with habitual / repeated wear like you describe, but it shouldn't be all that severe. The Energy is actually foam-encased to prevent that issue specifically. Have you measured how far it dips, or taken a picture of the sagging? If it is 2" or more of a slant, or if you can tell from the picture that it's a sharp drop-off, you should be able to speak with the DFW you purchased it from and have them start a warranty claim for you. And if you're not covered under warranty for whatever reason, a mattress topper (even a thin one) is a great way to flatten out the surface of the bed under the sheets :)
0
See full review+ 4 comments

Male
Review left on Feb 24, 2013

Achy mornings

I bought this mattress because I like the comfort of memory foam but not the heat. This one is also hot and I wake up with shoulder and back aches every morning. Will be losing my money b/c I am dumping this one.
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild Cool Coil Medley Plush
0
See full review

Female
Toni S
Review left on Feb 7, 2013

Doesnt feel right - sore back each day

After looking at many cheaper models due to budget - finally resolved to investing more and bought the plush on recommendation that I was best suited to a plush (from Sleepys sleep test) - had asked for firm and had great sleep on that type for years. Got it home and it just didn't feel the same as shop let alone something felt wrong. Like others I kept thinking am I sagging -is it my eyes etc. I turned mattress around toother end and although better still feels like I fall in a hole. I want to love it but after 4 weeks I still wake up achey. I also couldn't se how this would work in practicality if there were 2 people in bed at same time. We would be on top of each other. Kept salesman up to date days and weeks after purchase conscious of the trial deadline. Although a nice man got very little helpful/supportive support. Kept saying give it more time - the sag will reverse itself over time?.. Also spent more money on new pillows to try and see if that was affecting it. Helped but stil lower back aches. I want to believe it will get better but I believe something isn't right. Was told that to assess mattress for faulty takes two weeks but options weren't given til outside of trial etc etc. Going to revisit with sleepy as this was a lot of money for me and I can't imagine sleeping like this for next 5 years. Any advice welcome.
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image Radiant Plush

35 - 44 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

100-150 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

Official Response
Hi Toni, I'm so sorry to hear that you're having issues with your new Radiant Plush. Certainly go back to Sleepy's and address your concerns with them -- this is not typical of our mattresses and Sleepy's is trained to handle warranty issues related to unnatural dips or sags. As your salesman told you, it does take time to "break a mattress in" and get it to the comfort level that you might have felt on showroom models at the store. It is also necessary to rotate your mattress every 2-4 weeks the first few months that you own it to insure even wear. The other issue that jumps out to me is that you have always slept on a firm mattress, and switching to a plush after years of the same can be very jarring for your body. Though we love Sleepy's, a diagnostic test can only tell you so much and should simply guide you in a direction, your body needs to affirm the test's output. Please let us know if there is anything we can do to help -- we understand that a mattress is a big investment and we'd hate to think that a Warranty issue kept you from the sleep that you deserve.
0
See full review+ 7 comments

Male
Rona SNew York, NY
Review left on Feb 2, 2013

sublime sleep and customer service!

I first bought a CMG Radiant Plush at Sleepy's after I took their sleep diagnostic and was told I should have an EXTRA plush mattress. I was skeptical, but went with their assessment and bought the CMG Plush as it felt luxurious in the store. It took me a month and a half or so after purchase, to realize that my previously poor sleep got worse and now on top of that, I was waking up with aches and pains that I never had before! I asked CMG if I could exchange the plush for a firm and they supported me through the process of doing so with Sleepy's. (Note: I was slightly out of Sleepy's free comfort exchange time frame) With CMG's help, I had Sleepy's deliver my new firm mattress the very next morning and have been loving it ever since! Not only is this mattress comfortable and making my body feel good, it's eco-friendly (made from bamboo, which is a sustainable source and very breathable) and crafted in the USA which makes me happy. In conclusion, I highly recommend Carolina Mattress Guild as a company, and I love my new firm mattress. AND ALSO, if you take the Sleepy's sleep diagnostic test, take the results with a grain of salt and go with what you know!
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image Radiant Firm
Official Response
Hi Rona, We're so glad that the Radiant Firm ended up being the perfect mattress for you, and even happier to hear that our Customer Service team was able to help you work with Sleepy's and make your life a little easier! We love to hear stories like this, and we're ecstatic that you're so pleased with your mattress and with CMG. Please keep us updated on how your mattress is treating you (you can like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter to interact more easily!) and if there's anything else we can assist you with! Welcome to the CMG family :)
0
See full review+ 1 comment

Male
Brandon DGreenville, SC
Review left on Feb 1, 2013

Found a dealer in greenville sc

We would recommend anyone to shop at Mattress Outlet. We got a good deal and great service.Our mattress has allowed us to sleep more comfortable than ever
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild Natural Living
Official Response
That's great to hear, Brandon! So glad that you're loving your Peaceful and that the folks at Mattress Outlet were easy to work with! Thank you for buying American, and welcome to the CMG family! :)
0
See full review+ 1 comment

Male
Sue W
Review left on Jan 1, 2013

Best bed I've ever owned

Amazing bed. I always get a great night's sleep and I miss it when I'm away from home. We moved it from the US to London we love it so much. I would definitely buy another one.
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image Caress Extra Plush
Official Response
Glad to hear that you're loving your Caress, Sue!
0
See full review+ 1 comment

Male
Anatole BBrooklyn, NY
Review left on Oct 15, 2012

Beaut!

We went in sleepy's - lay around for a while, they guy was doing his best to sell us, went downstairs and both lay on the Carolina Radiant Plush Mattress, and we both had the same reaction, we felt so good on it, felt relaxed and knew it was what we wanted (we both had the same experience at the same time, which rarely happens), never had that experience on the 30 or so others we had tried before that - it had all natural fibers which appealed to my inner hippy, but I also think this is why we felt so relaxed on it, we bargained but didn't get a price we liked. So I came back and did a little research - finally came upon the Essential Plush at Olego, was very hesitant (didn't know what kind of guarantees there would be, and it being a online purchase and all), but it looked like it had even better features (like around 600 springs as apposed to around 400) and was much cheaper, in the 500 range as opposed to the 900 range. So we went for it, first few nights was slept on with the plastic due to renovations going on, but even then it was like a dream. After we took off the plastic it just got better, feels so relaxing and comforting, it's not mega soft, we were worried it would be too plush but its just right for us (we weigh in the 140-170 lbs range) - and I have never felt so comfortable in bed, although so far it's only been a couple weeks, which I know is very early to tell, but it makes such a difference to us both, and I saw a load of negative reviews on here before I bought it which didn't correlate with my experience in sleepy's so I had to add my 5 cents worth. So I highly rate this mattress! Will try and do a update later if I remember and have time! I have given 5 stars to durability, but that is after a couple weeks of use.
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild
Official Response
Anatole, we're so happy that you had a great experience with our brand! We work hard to make an eco-friendly, made in America product that mattress shoppers can see the value in. We appreciate your kind words, and welcome to the CMG family! Please do update us on the durability after you've had it for a while!
0
See full review+ 1 comment

Male
Cccrys CMyrtle Beach, SC
Review left on Oct 7, 2012

Perfect!

I also posted this comment under another review but I thought I would post on the main review page so others will see it. I love this mattress! I sent back my new Tempurpedic Cloud mattress after the 30 day comfort guarantee period. What a horrible 30 days that was! I hated that stinky, hard mattress. I would never purchase another memory foam. I can't tell you here how much that mattress stinks! I also don't like the "fall into the hole" feel where there is no give or bounce. Once you sink into the memory foam, you hit this really hard plateau and my husband and I both had aches where we had never had them before! This latex mattress provides just the right balance between memory foam on the surface and a bouncier feel. It has great firm-ish support and has given me relief from sciatic pain (I've had degenerative disks since my early 20's). I guess there is a right mattress for everyone but I think this is a great middle road between coils and memory foam - plus is it was way cheaper than the Tempur. Now, I can't speak to its longevity yet but I love, love, love, it. I hope it lasts forever!
This review is for Carolina Mattress Guild Nature's Image Caress Extra Plush
Official Response
Thank you so much for posting your review as it's own piece! We love to hear stories about great experiences like yours and we're so happy that you're pleased with your Caress! Welcome to the CMG family!
0
See full review+ 1 comment

123
4
5
...
52