Find the Right Bed
Comparison
Discounts
Reviews
Mattress 101
Sorry, the email address or password you entered is incorrect.

Forgot password?

Login successful.

Your screen name will look like: Your N from City, ST

VERIFY YOUR ACCOUNT

We just sent an email to

Open the message and click the link to access your account.

  • Expert Reviews
  • Expert Reviews
  • Customer Reviews
  • Popular Online Brands
  • Popular Store Brands
  • All Brands
  • Write a Review
  • Write Review
Close

Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush

Discontinued Product

Replacement Options
Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush Alternatives

Looking to replace your Blue 500 Plush mattress? This model has been discontinued and is no longer available, but here are 5 current models that are very similar – in terms of their materials & construction, comfort & feel, back support, and other performance characteristics we measure. Compare them side by side to determine which one is best for you.


$3,699
Queen Size
Shop this Bed

Compare These Products
Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush vs. Other Beds

Compare the Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush mattress side by side with other Serta models, or with mattresses from other brands.

GoodBed Expert Review
Our Take on Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush

Founder of GoodBed
Michael Magnuson

Founder of GoodBed, Leading Mattress Expert

Bottom Line - Here was our assessment of this product.
Bottom line best icon BEST if you
  • Want a medium-soft mattress (i.e., just a little softer than average)
  • Are mainly a side sleeper
  • Are easily disturbed by other movements in the bed (motion isolation is excellent)
  • Have a clear preference for being hugged or cradled by your mattress
  • Prefer an above average amount of 'memory feel'
  • Would like a mattress that performs very well when used with an adjustable base
Bottom line not ideal icon NOT IDEAL if you
  • Are a stomach sleeper, especially if you weigh more than 250 lb
  • Like your mattress to have some bounce
  • Sleep close to the edge of your bed sometimes
  • Have a natural tendency to sleep hot
  • Are seeking the absolute highest quality and longevity (though materials and construction are still pretty good)

GoodBed Ratings

Our Measurements and Scores for the Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush
These attributes are not 'better' or 'worse' — they should be judged solely on your personal preference.
Softness
Medium-Soft (6)
Cushioning
Depth
Very Deep (8)
Memory Feel
High (7)
Bounce
Very Low (2)
Durability
Pretty Good (6)
Warranty
10-year
warranty
Quality
Pretty Good (6)
Spinal alignment depends on "fit" between your body and the mattress.
Lighter Weight
(<150 lb.)
Side Sleeper
Back Sleeper
Stomach Sleeper
Excellent (9)
Very Good (8)
OK (5)
Average Weight
(150-200 lb.)
Side Sleeper
Back Sleeper
Stomach Sleeper
Very Good (8)
Good (7)
Fair (4)
Above Average
Weight
(200-250 lb.)
Side Sleeper
Back Sleeper
Stomach Sleeper
Very Good (8)
Good (7)
Fair (3)
Heavier Weight
(>250 lb.)
Side Sleeper
Back Sleeper
Stomach Sleeper
Good (7)
Pretty Good (6)
Fair (3)
Pressure relief depends on "fit" between your body and the mattress, and is most important for side sleepers.
Lighter Weight
(<150 lb.)
Typical Curves
Extra Curvy
Excellent (9)
Excellent (9)
Average Weight
(150-200 lb.)
Typical Curves
Extra Curvy
Excellent (9)
Excellent (9)
Above Average
Weight
(200-250 lb.)
Typical Curves
Extra Curvy
Very Good (8)
Very Good (8)
Heavier Weight
(>250 lb.)
Typical Curves
Extra Curvy
Good (7)
Good (7)
These attributes can be 'better' or 'worse' — but may or may not be a priority for you.
Motion
Isolation
Excellent (9)
Sleeps Cool
Fair (4)
Edge Support
Fair (3)
Reposition
Ease
Fair (4)
Green
Features
Fair (3)
Adjustable
Base
Suitability
Very Good (8)

Find the Right Mattress

Not sure which bed is best for you? We can assess your needs. Let’s start...What is your preferred sleep position?

“The GoodBed Quiz is by far the best starting point for any mattress shopper.” – Katherine P. in Chicago, IL

Answer a few questions to see the best options for you based on the most advanced mattress matching algorithm on the internet.

Frequently Asked Questions
Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush

  • In our evaluation of the Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush mattress, we found it to be a Medium-Soft (6) on the GoodBed rating scale (1= firmest, 9 = softest).
  • Yes, the Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush mattress is adjustable base compatible. This means it is designed to be used on an adjustable base without incurring damage or voiding the warranty. In our review of this mattress, we tested it on an adjustable base to look for any adverse effects as the head and foot are elevated, and to see how well it conforms to the contours of the base both with and without the weight of a sleeper. Overall, we found the Blue 500 Plush to have very good adjustable base compatibility.

Reviews Blue 500 Plush

Expert Q&A

See questions from other mattress buyers

Additional Information

General Description

¾” TempActiv™ Gel Memory Foam:• The TempActiv™ Gel Memory Foam is infused with gel cooling beads that helps the Memory Foam absorb and dissipate excess heat, while still providing pressure relieving support.

2” EverCool® Fuze Gel Memory Foam:• The EverCool® Fuze Gel Memory Foam is a conforming and supportive foam that is infused with Gel to provide a cooler feel to the Memory Foam.

1.5” EverCool® Supreme Memory Foam:• The EverCool® Supreme Memory Foam offers a Plush yet supportive feel.

Serta® Ultimate Edge® Foam Support Core:• Advanced foam system helps support your body throughout the night. Built to be extremely durable for support night after night. Ultimate Edge® Support strengthens the mattress edges to prevent roll off and longer mattress life.


From the GoodBed Editors:

To decide whether a Serta iComfort mattress is right for you, see our video update for an in-depth explanation of the iComfort Blue mattresses.

 


Mattress Specifications:

  • Gel Memory Foam Details: 3/4" TempActiv™ Gel Memory Foam
  • Foam Details: 7" Serta® Ultimate Edge® Foam Core

Warranty

  • Length: 10-year warranty.
  • Indentation coverage: 0.75" and deeper.
  • Other Notes: Some warranties may be pro-rated. Check law label for details..

About This Model

Status Discontinued
Line Serta iComfort (2017-2019)
Collection Serta iComfort (Foam) (2017-2019)
Comfort Level Medium-Soft
Surface Type Unquilted
Build Details
  • No-Flip
  • Mattress Thickness: 11.25"

Corrections

Have an update or correction to our information about Serta iComfort Blue 500 Plush? If so, please take a moment to suggest an edit.

Best Discounts + Cash Back

Did you know? GoodBed is the only mattress shopping website that shares our referral fees with you. This means you get free Cash Back from us – on top of the discounts from the brand. Check out popular offers below, or search across all online mattress deals.

Ready to find your mattress?

Take the GoodBed Match Quiz

“The GoodBed Quiz is by far the best starting point for any mattress shopper.” – Katherine P. in Chicago, IL