Corsicana
Mattress Ratings & Reviews

Corsicana logo
81/100
Very Good
Back Support
57
Pressure Relief
62
Sleep Quality
64
Stays "Cool"
68
Value
42
Warranty Service
40
Average Lifespan
7.9 Years

Not sure this product is right for you?

Take the

GoodBed Match Quiz
Back Support
57
Pressure Relief
62
Sleep Quality
64
Stays "Cool"
68
Value
42
Warranty Service
40
Average Lifespan
7.9 Years

Not sure this product is right for you?

Take the

GoodBed Match Quiz
FILTER
840 total ratings, 88 with reviews
Female
Michelle JLa Porte, IN
Review left on Jul 23, 2011

I've slept on more comfortable floors

We bought the bed in June of 2010 and by Christmas we were trying to get the bed replaced. The store where we bought it from was closing for the winter and we ended up having to wait until today for a replacement, it is currently July 2011. 8 months we had to wait for some resolution and who knows this bed may fail just bad as the other. We started off with the Chesapeke it was amazing for about a week then from there down hill. We were so disappointed because we had shopped and shopped for what we thought was going to be a good bed. The mattress collapsed on the one side and the center of the bed had a massive lump in it my husband and I could not even roll over to snuggle since there was a lump in the way. The only thing I can say positive about the bed was the lump we stopped smacking each other in our sleep.....LOL but really it was a waste of out money next time I am buying a sleep number bed my friend has one and she says hers is amazing.... It costs a bit more but it's worth it for a good night's sleep.
This review is for Corsicana

Female

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

0
See full review+ 6 comments

Male
Neal HHenderson, NV
Review left on May 24, 2011

sink hole

This mattress is the worst mattress I have ever owned. The sink hole is just getting worse and worse. I called the store to complain, and they sent out two guys to evaluate the problem. They concluded the frame was not supporting the mattress the way it should, causing the "sinkhole". I regret not forcing them to "retest" it without the frame. I got a letter a few weeks later saying its the frame, not the mattress. It has the same problem without the frame, just on the floor. Not only will I avoid this brand, I will never buy anything from that store again. Why have a warranty that just shifts blame away from their faulty product? The warranty guys and their smoke and mirrors "testing". They used string and office supply binder clips along with a paper ring with a ruler. This ring looked like a burger king crown for kids. the sag was VERY noticeable, and they still simply blamed the frame. It was a joke, and a waste of my time.
This review is for Corsicana Colonial Williamsburg

Male

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

0
See full review

Female
C SNewport News, VA
Review left on Apr 23, 2011

Worst mattress ever

Worst mattress ever! We bought this in 2009 and have suffered since. We are going to get a new mattress today. It is not worth paying a cheap price and buying an off brand. Mattress is very soft and offers no support, it is now lumpy and there are dips on each side where my husband and I sleep. I have aches and pains in my back, ribs and sholder area every single day, where I never had them before. Only reason why we bought a new mattress in the first place is because we upgraded from a Queen to a King
This review is for Corsicana Colonial Halifax

Female

Stomach Sleeper

150-200 lbs

0
See full review

Female
Toni PFairview, TN
Review left on Feb 18, 2011

TERRIBLE MATTRESS

Wasted my hard earned $800.00 and had to endure 2-1/2 years of extremely uncomfortable conditions. The mattess was turned regularly and to no avail just sank deeper and deeper and maintained the sag area with absolutely no recovery. The mattress was beautiful in appearance but certainly lacking in any kind of continous support. The sagging started occuring within six months of purchase.
This review is for Corsicana

Female

Side Sleeper

0
See full review

Female
Alma FUnion, SC
Review left on Jan 31, 2011

Disappointed in Carolina

The "X Firm" mattress is nothing more than a bunch of foam that causes excruciating pain to my neck, back, and hip. I've had the mattress since November 13, 2010 and a big disappointment. I wasted $694.93. I will alert everyone I know that is looking for a firm mattress. They named the springs right on this one. It is nothing more than a box, which I’m sure would serve a firmer purpose than the mattress.
This review is for Corsicana

Female

Side Sleeper

0
See full review

Male
Don MFort Worth, TX
Review left on Jan 22, 2011

Corsicana Halifax

Very soft, on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being firm, I would say this mattress is about a 5. Very comfy. It has 1.5 inches of quilt foam on top of 3 inches of the good tempurpedic type foam. you feel yourself squish down in it slowly over the first few minutes, but just enough to relieve pressure off the heavy parts of your body, you know, like my hips and shoulders sink into the foam a couple inches but you dont sink down into it like a hammock, its got good firm support underneath, and its very quiet too, since the coils are all individually wrapped, i can have s*x with my wife and the kids have no idea what we're doing, haha. This mattress is a good 14" thick so we used the king fitted sheet off our old bed and it fits. This is an over sized high quality mattress. An expert told me if you feel the sides of the mattress and it is soft, it is a crappy mattress and will give out after a short time. You want to feel the sides and feel a firm side, which this one is. It has what the call "edge support" so you can sit on the edge an it feels firm. I weigh 230 lbs and this mattress does not let me "sink down" into the middle, and when I get out there is no "crater" in the middle. All in all I would say it was well worth the $650 we paid for it.
This review is for Corsicana Colonial Halifax

Male

Side Sleeper

200-250 lbs

0
See full review

Female
Jody CGirard, KS
Review left on Dec 28, 2010

In the Pits!

My husband and I bought this mattress and after 8 nights, felt like we were sleeping in a coffin---we just sunk further and further down. We had awful lower back pain, numbness/tingling in our shoulders and arms (couldn't possibly roll over in our "holes"), etc. Tried to return it--more nightmares! The store finally exchanged it--after insinuating that we were idiots and liars--for another just like it. The indentations from the straps used to secure it in our truck are still there--not even sure it is worth putting up. Think I'll call a lawyer tomorrow to see if ANYTHING can be done.
This review is for Corsicana

Female

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

0
See full review+ 1 comment

Male
Paul RPittsburgh, PA
Review left on Dec 10, 2010

Good night sleep

This is an excellent mattress for the price($450). My girlfriend has an Ikea mattress she bought for $600 and we both agree that this one is just as comfortable. Good support, wake up feeling good in the morning. Good price. No need for a foundation, I use it with bedframe that does not require a foundation and it works great.
This review is for Corsicana Pinnacle

Male

Back Sleeper

150-200 lbs

0
See full review

Male
DeanBenton, IL
Review left on Sep 15, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support
3/ 5
Pressure Relief
4/ 5
Sleep Quality
N/A
Stays "Cool"
3/ 5
Value
N/A
Warranty Service
N/A
This review is for Corsicana Brigham
Owned for: 15 years
Condition: Moderately worn

Over 65 years old

Male

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

Back Pain, Neck Pain, Sleeping Hot

0

Male
Brooklyn, NY
Review left on Aug 30, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support
2/ 5
Pressure Relief
N/A
Sleep Quality
3/ 5
Stays "Cool"
2/ 5
Value
N/A
Warranty Service
N/A
This review is for Corsicana
Owned for: 6 years
Condition: Very worn

55 - 64 years old

Male

Back Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

Back Pain, Fibromyalgia, Sleeping Hot

0

1
...
8
9
10
...
84
Corsicana Mattress Reviews - Page 9 | GoodBed