Simmons BeautySleep (Pre-2017)
Mattress Ratings & Reviews

Simmons BeautySleep (Pre-2017) logo
81/100
Very Good
Back Support
62
Pressure Relief
62
Sleep Quality
65
Stays "Cool"
68
Value
42
Warranty Service
38
Average Lifespan
10.2 Years
Back Support
62
Pressure Relief
62
Sleep Quality
65
Stays "Cool"
68
Value
42
Warranty Service
38
Average Lifespan
10.2 Years
FILTER
2,639 total ratings, 27 with reviews
Male
Mike
Review left on Jun 24, 2024

Atrociously Awful Night's Sleep

I sat on this mattress and others just like it. They were mush. There's a huge difference between plush and mush. Plush is luxurious. Mush is painful. Completely inadequate support. This mattress is atrociously painful...horrible low back pain after just a few hours. No way to get comfortable. I can sleep comfortably almost anywhere in any position...side, back, abdomen. This mattress is PAINFUL in EVERY position...side, back, abdomen.
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep Astoria Pillowtop
Owned for: Less than a year
Condition: Slightly worn

Over 65 years old

Male

Stomach Sleeper

100-150 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

0
See full review

Female
DvonCanton, MI
Review left on Nov 20, 2020

Don’t purchase

Broken springs in bed in less than 1 yr. Art Van went bankrupt and our warranty went with it. Horrible bed!
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep Finleyville Firm
Owned for: 2 years
Condition: Completely worn

55 - 64 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

200-250 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

Arthritis, Plus Size, Sleep Apnea

0
See full review

Female
vondaEvansville, IN
Review left on Nov 3, 2019

Not what I expected

I am a side sleeper and within a week of having this mattress my hips hurt about and hour into sleeping. Tried to exchange with Ashley Furniture within that week and they would not exchange or let me return. I told the salesman I did not want a mattress with memory foam and this is what he suggested. I don't think he knew what he was selling.
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep 450 Plush PillowTop
Owned for: 4 years
Condition: Like new

55 - 64 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

100-150 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

Allergies, Hip Pain, Neck Pain

0
See full review

Male
Terry MMemphis, TN
Review left on Jul 23, 2019

This the worst mattress I have ever slept on. It sags. This

This mattress has me and my wife back neck shoulders hurting. I hate this mattress. This is the 3rd replacement for our adjustable base bed. This mattress is not good for the adjustable base beds
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep Cascade Mountain Plush
Owned for: 6-12 months
Condition: Moderately worn
0
See full review

Male
charlesSterling, MI
Review left on May 22, 2019

Junk, do not buy one, now they tell me it's discontinued,...

Junk, do not buy one, now they tell me it's discontinued, so now arguing with place of purchase on both box spring and mattress! both junk. place of purchase should have told me they were discontinued models.
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep Blaine Plush
Owned for: 1-3 months
Condition: Completely worn

35 - 44 years old

Male

Don't know Sleeper

> 300 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

Sleep Apnea

0
See full review

Female
VamrOttawa, ON
Review left on Feb 3, 2019

Had a slight dip in middle of bed ,and one side softer an...

Had a slight dip in middle of bed ,and one side softer and somewhat saggier than the other from the beginning . On day 2 of receiving I thought I should turn it around as other side seems just right. Leons will be replacing it for same, hopefully no defects Ultra Garrett cushion firm mattress next time. Was on sale. so if same all over a good buy and value, Lady said 50-50 % chance the next one will be the same. I don't believe that's possible or Leon's would have an issue w Beautyrest. I HAD A BETTER SLEEP ALREADY,but I want it same all over.I bought box spring and mattress cover to get the warrantee.
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep (Pre-2017)
Condition: Like new

Over 65 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

200-250 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

Back Pain, Restricted Mobility, Hip Pain, Osteoporosis, Plus Size

0
See full review

Female
NancyMurfreesboro, TN
Review left on Jan 3, 2019

Sleeping in the valley

After about a year, this bed began to develop significant depressions on both sides which have made sleep difficult and caused back pain for my husband and myself. Our previous mattress was comfortable for more than 15 years, so we were surprised and very disappointed to find this mattress nearly unusable after just two years. Today we submitted a warranty claim with Simmons and are waiting to hear their response.
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep Marnie Pillow Top
Owned for: 2 years
Condition: Very worn

55 - 64 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

Sleep Apnea

0
See full review

Female
Vicky LShow Low, AZ
Review left on Nov 20, 2018

Sags

I'm soo unhappy and deprived of sleep. This is the second mattress I've had from this place and both sagged within a month. Now the business says they won't refund my 500.00 bucks. The beds make my hip bones hurt and sometimes my arms fall asleep. Very dissatisfied.
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep Cascade Mountain Plush
Owned for: Less than a year
Condition: Very worn

55 - 64 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

100-150 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

Arthritis, Back Pain, Hip Pain, Neck Pain

0
See full review

Male
LisaDavenport, IA
Review left on Sep 2, 2018

Horrid! Do not purchase

We originally purchased this mattress 3 years ago. Within 2 months we had a warranty claim and for sagging in the middle. So we get the next one and it lasted about 18 months or so. Filed another claim. Got a 3 mattress delivered for $85, and it has lasted 6 weeks. This one is worse than the others. 3inch depression in the center. Turned in another claim and said under no circumstances do we want this piece of #@@%, again. Waiting to here from Simmons. Worst purchase ever. But I will say the warranty claim has been processed quickly. Only good thing.
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep Beaver Creek Plush
Owned for: Less than a year
Condition: Completely worn

Under 25 years old

Male

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

0
See full review

Male
KOld Hickory, TN
Review left on Jul 21, 2018

Best month of sleep ever, but only a month.

It is the most flimsy mattress I've ever slept on. It feels like a heavenly cloud at first. You think wonderful thoughts of, "holy cow, what an awesome deal! What are people doing wasting money on the high end stuff?" Then, a month goes by. You already have a 3-5 inch depression where you sleep. So...you return it, pay the $100 shipping for a new one, and chock it up to bad manufacturing. Only...the replacement turns into crater city within a month, too. Do NOT buy this mattress. It is deceiving instore and on the first few weeks of ownership, but its life is measured in weeks, not years. I have MAJOR lower back pain from this junk pile of a mattress, and can barely put my socks on at the ripe old age of 25. Seriously, DO NOT GET THIS MATTRESS, unless you are under 150 lbs and never sleep in the same spot twice.
This review is for Simmons BeautySleep Beaver Creek Plush
Owned for: 6-12 months
Condition: Very worn

25 - 34 years old

Male

Stomach Sleeper

200-250 lbs

Prefers Softer Feel

Acid Reflux, Back Pain, Sleep Apnea

0
See full review