Sealy Posture Premier
Mattress Ratings & Reviews

84/100

Very Good

Based on 929 real owner experiences with this brand.

Back Support

Pressure Relief

Sleep Quality

Stays "Cool"

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

Average Lifespan

8.5 Years

Shop this Brand

on sealy.com

Not sure this product is right for you?

Take the

GoodBed Match Quiz

Write a review of this product

Back Support

Pressure Relief

Sleep Quality

Stays "Cool"

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

Average Lifespan

8.5 Years

Shop this Brand

on sealy.com

Not sure this product is right for you?

Take the

GoodBed Match Quiz

Write a review of this product

FILTER

929 total ratings, 3 with reviews

Sort by:

KristaCincinnati, OH

Review left on Jan 9, 2015

Dont get it!!!

We purchased this mattress 6 years ago and was told we have a 10 year warranty on it. Come to find out its a 3 year warranty after i took the time to email the pictures and measurements and was denied a new bed. So sears lied just letting anyone know that cares. thanks

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier Luxury Pillowtop

Owned for: 6 years

Condition: Completely worn

35 - 44 years old

Female

Back Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Somewhat Harder

See full review

Hugh PPort Sydney, ON

Review left on Sep 20, 2013

Disappointed

We purchased this mattress with the expectation that it would last -- paid top dollar, and from a "respected" manufacturer. The mattress was great for the first year or so then it went down hill. The manufactures method of measuring sag is flawed and is only intended to provide them with a way out of dealing with warranty claims --- By the time your mattress means their criteria you would have replaced it long before. A 6 year old mattress, and $2200 down the drain. My $800 non name mattress on my previous bed lasted much long, and is still in us by others 15 years later.

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier Luxury Pillowtop

Owned for: More than 3 months

Condition: Completely worn

55 - 64 years old

Male

Back Sleeper

200-250 lbs

Prefers Somewhat Harder

See full review

Mike SBayonne, NJ

Review left on Feb 27, 2011

Dissapointed

We placed an order for a Sealy Posture Premier Islandia Plush. We recieved a Starlight Isle PL ? It did not look like the matterss on thier internet sight. I even confirmed two times when placing the order at the begining and the end that we were going to recieve the mattress on the net I was told yes, the 2011 model. We called to voice our concern and were given all kinds of nonsense. If Sleepys is the parent company they should do a better job of delivering what the show on the net. I would NOT order from them again

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier

Male

Side Sleeper

200-250 lbs

See full review+ 4 comments

Review left on Jan 27, 2026

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

2/ 5

Pressure Relief

1/ 5

Sleep Quality

N/A

Stays "Cool"

4/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier

Owned for: 20 years

Condition: Moderately worn

35 - 44 years old

Male

Side Sleeper

> 300 lbs

Prefers Medium

Airborne Allergies, Asthma, Back Pain (lower / middle), Hip Pain, Back Pain (upper / neck), Plus Size, Restless Leg, Shoulder Pain, Sleep Apnea

Review left on Aug 4, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

3/ 5

Pressure Relief

3/ 5

Sleep Quality

2/ 5

Stays "Cool"

4/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier

Owned for: 3 years

Condition: Very worn

25 - 34 years old

Male

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium

Airborne Allergies, Sleeping Hot

Review left on Jul 19, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

4/ 5

Pressure Relief

4/ 5

Sleep Quality

5/ 5

Stays "Cool"

4/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier Luxury Pillowtop

Owned for: 4 years

Condition: Slightly worn

Over 65 years old

Male

Stomach Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Somewhat Harder

Airborne Allergies, Arthritis, Back Pain (lower / middle), Hip Pain, Back Pain (upper / neck), Restless Leg

Review left on Jul 10, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

5/ 5

Pressure Relief

4/ 5

Sleep Quality

5/ 5

Stays "Cool"

4/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier

Owned for: 20 years

Condition: Moderately worn

25 - 34 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium

Acid Reflux, Back Pain (lower / middle), Hip Pain, Restless Leg

RominaMenlo Park, CA

Review left on May 18, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

1/ 5

Pressure Relief

2/ 5

Sleep Quality

N/A

Stays "Cool"

3/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier

Owned for: More than 20 years

Condition: Very worn

55 - 64 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Somewhat Harder

Airborne Allergies, Back Pain (lower / middle), Fibromyalgia, Back Pain (upper / neck), Plus Size, Scoliosis, Sleep Apnea, Sleeping Hot

LindaAltoona, PA

Review left on Apr 4, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

4/ 5

Pressure Relief

2/ 5

Sleep Quality

3/ 5

Stays "Cool"

N/A

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier Luxury Pillowtop

Owned for: More than 20 years

Condition: Very worn

Side Sleeper

Prefers Medium

Acid Reflux, Arthritis, Hip Pain, Back Pain (upper / neck), Osteoporosis

Review left on May 23, 2024

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

2/ 5

Pressure Relief

3/ 5

Sleep Quality

3/ 5

Stays "Cool"

4/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posture Premier

Owned for: 10 years

Condition: Moderately worn

55 - 64 years old

Female

150-200 lbs

Prefers Somewhat Harder

Back Pain (lower / middle), Back Pain (upper / neck), Osteoporosis

2 3 4 5

...

Find the Right Bed

Compare Side-by-Side

Popular Mattress Comparisons

Discounts

GoodBed Cash Back

Expert Reviews

Popular Online Brands

Popular Store Brands

Write a Review

Mattress 101

The GoodBed Matching Quiz

Expert Reviews

Customer Reviews

Sealy Posture Premier
Mattress Ratings & Reviews

Dont get it!!!

Disappointed

Dissapointed

Find the Right Bed

Compare Side-by-Side

Popular Mattress Comparisons

Discounts

GoodBed Cash Back

Expert Reviews

Popular Online Brands

Popular Store Brands

Write a Review

Mattress 101

The GoodBed Matching Quiz

Expert Reviews

Customer Reviews

Sealy Posture Premier Mattress Ratings & Reviews

Dont get it!!!

Disappointed

Dissapointed

Sealy Posture Premier
Mattress Ratings & Reviews