Sealy Response Premium
Mattress Ratings & Reviews

83/100

Very Good

Based on 161 real owner experiences with this brand.

Back Support

Pressure Relief

Sleep Quality

Stays "Cool"

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

Average Lifespan

N/A

Shop this Brand

on sealy.com

Not sure this product is right for you?

Take the

GoodBed Match Quiz

Write a review of this product

Back Support

Pressure Relief

Sleep Quality

Stays "Cool"

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

Average Lifespan

N/A

Shop this Brand

on sealy.com

Not sure this product is right for you?

Take the

GoodBed Match Quiz

Write a review of this product

FILTER

161 total ratings, 3 with reviews

Sort by:

BradGretna, NE

Review left on Nov 18, 2020

Develops 'memory' trenches

I expected that the mattress wouldn't cause me back and neck pain after 1 year. Silly me! My wife says the same thing. After 2 years we are giving up and going back to traditional coil system. We're not cut out for the 14 inch gel toppers.

This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Premium Winnifred Plush

Owned for: 2 years

Condition: Slightly worn

35 - 44 years old

Male

Back Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

See full review

LynePoplarville, MS

Review left on Aug 28, 2020

Best sleep ever!

This mattress is considered a plush mattress but I think it has the perfect amount of softness and firmness. It sinks in a little when you lay down while still giving your body support. Best pain free sleep I’ve had in over a year since my old Sealy started to wear after years of owning.

This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Premium Seaside Mist Plush

Owned for: Less than a year

Condition: Like new

25 - 34 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

200-250 lbs

Prefers Softer Feel

Acid Reflux, Allergies, Back Pain, Hip Pain, Neck Pain, Plus Size, Sleeping Hot

See full review

OCLos Angeles, CA

Review left on Jun 3, 2020

Excellent support with softness! Longevity is questionable.

I bought this one at Costco, but it's the same as the other branded versions of Sealy Posturepedic Response Premium Plush Pillowtop 14". (A good source is US Mattress dot com for the various names this goes under at any given time across retailers.) So, the price is excellent, and I got it on sale to boot. And out of all the mattresses I tried, I realized I hated the sunk feeling of memory foam, preferred good edge support and the springy feel of an innerspring, but absolutely require both amazing alignment and back support while sleeping on my side as well as zero pressure points. For reference, I have a very curvy body build with wide hips, small waist, large chest and medium shoulders. I am almost always a side sleeper, but do wake up on my back sometimes. This mattress is great for me for BOTH positions - I am always cushioned and held in alignment. AMAZING!! I do wake up in some pain at times, but I have some other issues going on that are causing that. The mattress itself has been really good for alignment. That "posturepedic" support thing is real! But, I fear for its longevity. The soft foams I need for cushion and pressure point relief do start to develop body impressions pretty quickly, and you have to rotate as well as sleep all over the mattress to try to keep permanent body impressions to a minimum. The great thing about shopping mattresses at Costco is they will take it back and refund you fully anytime during the warranty period (10 years for this one) if the mattress fails to meet expectations. So, I'm going to go with it for a while, and see where it gets me. Once the stores are open again post-Coronapocalypse, I'll also be checking out the Purple 4 (but really: it's too heavy to be practical, and you're not supposed to use a heating blanket which I always do in the winter) and the new Casper Nova Hybrid. The Nova Hybrid actually sounds pretty perfect for me except that edge support seems not that great - not a HUGE deal, but I like having it. Hope this review helps you!

This review is for Sealy Response Premium Ridge Crest Plush

Owned for: 2 years

Condition: Slightly worn

45 - 54 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Softer Feel

Back Pain, Hip Pain, Neck Pain, Plus Size, Sleeping Hot

See full review

Cincinnati, OH

Review left on Jul 16, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

3/ 5

Pressure Relief

4/ 5

Sleep Quality

N/A

Stays "Cool"

2/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Response Premium Ridge Crest Plush

Owned for: 7 years

Condition: Moderately worn

25 - 34 years old

Male

Back Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

BryanSalt Lake City, UT

Review left on May 23, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

3/ 5

Pressure Relief

2/ 5

Sleep Quality

2/ 5

Stays "Cool"

3/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Response Premium Ridge Crest Plush

Owned for: 3-6 months

Condition: Slightly worn

Over 65 years old

Male

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Softer Feel

Back Pain, Sleeping Hot

PaulUnion, KY

Review left on Apr 26, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

3/ 5

Pressure Relief

4/ 5

Sleep Quality

2/ 5

Stays "Cool"

4/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Response Premium Barrett Court IV Cushion Firm Pillowtop

Owned for: 4 years

Condition: Moderately worn

Over 65 years old

Male

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

Back Pain, Neck Pain

MarcusFrisco, TX

Review left on Mar 14, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

3/ 5

Pressure Relief

3/ 5

Sleep Quality

3/ 5

Stays "Cool"

3/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Premium Winnifred Plush Euro Pillowtop

Owned for: 8 years

Condition: Very worn

45 - 54 years old

Male

200-250 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

Acid Reflux, Hip Pain, Plus Size, Sleeping Hot

Olathe, KS

Review left on Feb 18, 2025

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

4/ 5

Pressure Relief

4/ 5

Sleep Quality

5/ 5

Stays "Cool"

4/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Premium Winnifred Plush Euro Pillowtop

Owned for: 7 years

Condition: Moderately worn

35 - 44 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

200-250 lbs

Prefers Softer Feel

Acid Reflux, Allergies, Plus Size, Scoliosis, Sleeping Hot

JessicaOxnard, CA

Review left on Dec 28, 2024

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

3/ 5

Pressure Relief

3/ 5

Sleep Quality

3/ 5

Stays "Cool"

3/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Response Premium Ridge Crest Firm

Owned for: 5 years

Condition: Moderately worn

45 - 54 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

Back Pain, Hip Pain, Neck Pain, Restless Leg, Sleeping Hot

Plano, TX

Review left on Nov 24, 2024

Ratings from this sleeper:

Back Support

3/ 5

Pressure Relief

2/ 5

Sleep Quality

5/ 5

Stays "Cool"

3/ 5

Value

N/A

Warranty Service

N/A

This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Premium Winnifred Cushion Firm

Owned for: 7 years

Condition: Moderately worn

Over 65 years old

Male

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

Back Pain, Hip Pain

2 3 4 5

...

Find the Right Bed

Compare Side-by-Side

Popular Mattress Comparisons

Discounts

GoodBed Cash Back

Expert Reviews

Popular Online Brands

Popular Store Brands

Write a Review

Mattress 101

The GoodBed Matching Quiz

Expert Reviews

Customer Reviews

Sealy Response Premium
Mattress Ratings & Reviews

Develops 'memory' trenches

Best sleep ever!

Excellent support with softness! Longevity is questionable.

Find the Right Bed

Compare Side-by-Side

Popular Mattress Comparisons

Discounts

GoodBed Cash Back

Expert Reviews

Popular Online Brands

Popular Store Brands

Write a Review

Mattress 101

The GoodBed Matching Quiz

Expert Reviews

Customer Reviews

Sealy Response Premium Mattress Ratings & Reviews

Develops 'memory' trenches

Best sleep ever!

Excellent support with softness! Longevity is questionable.

Sealy Response Premium
Mattress Ratings & Reviews