Find the Right Bed
Nearby Stores
Comparison
Discounts
Reviews
Mattress 101
GoodBed Quiz
Search

Find the Right Bed

Goodbed Match Quiz
GoodBed Match Quiz
Mattresses at Nearby Stores
Mattresses at Nearby Stores
Mattresses Available Online
Mattresses Available Online

Compare Side-by-Side

Compare mattresses side by side

Choose from hundreds of mattress brands and models to compare.

Create a Comparison

Popular Mattress Comparisons

    GoodBed Cash Back

    GoodBed Cash Back

    Get extra cash back from GoodBed after purchase – stacked on top of the best discounts from the retailer.

    See GoodBed Cash Back offers + how it works
    • Expert Reviews
    • Expert Reviews
    • Customer Reviews
    • Popular Online Brands
    • Popular Store Brands
    • All Brands
    • Write a Review
    • Write Review

    Expert Reviews

    View 100+ Expert Reviews
    • Avocado - Mattress Reviews
    • Beautyrest - Mattress Reviews
    • Brooklyn Bedding - Mattress Reviews
    • Casper - Mattress Reviews
    • DreamCloud - Mattress Reviews
    • Helix - Mattress Reviews
    • Nectar - Mattress Reviews
    • Purple - Mattress Reviews
    • Saatva - Mattress Reviews
    • Sealy - Mattress Reviews
    • Serta - Mattress Reviews
    • Stearns & Foster - Mattress Reviews
    • TEMPUR-Pedic - Mattress Reviews
    • Tuft & Needle - Mattress Reviews
    • WinkBed - Mattress Reviews

    Popular Online Brands

    View All Online Brands
    • Avocado Mattress Reviews
    • Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Reviews
    • Casper Mattress Reviews
    • DreamCloud Mattress Reviews
    • Leesa Mattress Reviews
    • Nectar Mattress Reviews
    • Nest Bedding Mattress Reviews
    • Puffy Mattress Reviews
    • Purple Mattress Reviews
    • Saatva Mattress Reviews
    • Tuft & Needle Mattress Reviews
    • WinkBed Mattress Reviews

    Popular Store Brands

    View All Store Brands
    • Beautyrest Mattress Reviews
    • Englander Mattress Reviews
    • IKEA Mattress Reviews
    • King Koil Mattress Reviews
    • Restonic Mattress Reviews
    • Sealy Mattress Reviews
    • Serta Mattress Reviews
    • Sleep Number Mattress Reviews
    • Sleepys Mattress Reviews
    • Spring Air Mattress Reviews
    • Stearns & Foster Mattress Reviews
    • TEMPUR-Pedic Mattress Reviews

    Write a Review

    Rate Your Mattress
    Rate Your Mattress
    Rate a Mattress Retailer
    Rate a Mattress Retailer

    Mattress 101

    Types of Mattresses
    Types of Mattresses
    How to choose a Mattress - the 3 F's
    How to Choose a Mattress - the 3 F's
    What to Avoid
    What to Avoid
    Expert Q&A
    Expert Q&A
    Customer Discussion Forum
    Customer Discussion Forum
    Related Products
    Related Products
    Mattress Glossary
    Mattress Glossary

    The GoodBed Matching Quiz

    GoodBed Quiz

    Find your perfect mattress match in a few minutes, searching across all major brands and retailers.

    Learn more about the Quiz
    Close
    Reviews

    Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Mattress Ratings & Reviews

    Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop logo
    84/100
    Very Good
    Based on 10 real owner experiences with this mattress.

    We’re still working on collecting customer reviews for this product, but don’t yet have enough to provide a summary of customer feedback. In the meantime, we recommend looking at reviews for all Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) products.

    Shop this Brand

    on sealy.com

    Not sure this product is right for you?

    Take the

    GoodBed Match Quiz
    Write a review of this product

    We’re still working on collecting customer reviews for this product, but don’t yet have enough to provide a summary of customer feedback. In the meantime, we recommend looking at reviews for all Sealy Posturepedic (Pre-2017) products.

    Shop this Brand

    on sealy.com

    Not sure this product is right for you?

    Take the

    GoodBed Match Quiz
    Write a review of this product
    FILTER
    10 total ratings, 1 with review
    Male
    Justin BSeattle, WA
    Review left on Jan 23, 2010

    Sealy Posturepedic

    This is probably the best bed I've ever slept in. Great support, but the pillowtop make it really comfortable. My wife and I have owned this bed for ~2 yrs. and have have frequently commented about what a great investment it was.
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop

    Back Sleeper

    150-200 lbs

    0
    See full review
    Male
    Review left on Mar 31, 2024

    Ratings from this sleeper:

    Back Support
    5/ 5
    Pressure Relief
    5/ 5
    Sleep Quality
    5/ 5
    Stays "Cool"
    5/ 5
    Value
    N/A
    Warranty Service
    N/A
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Owned for: 8 years
    Condition: Slightly worn

    25 - 34 years old

    Male

    Side Sleeper

    150-200 lbs

    Prefers Somewhat Softer

    0
    Female
    Review left on Feb 16, 2024

    Ratings from this sleeper:

    Back Support
    3/ 5
    Pressure Relief
    2/ 5
    Sleep Quality
    5/ 5
    Stays "Cool"
    1/ 5
    Value
    N/A
    Warranty Service
    N/A
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Owned for: 17 years
    Condition: Moderately worn

    35 - 44 years old

    Female

    Side Sleeper

    150-200 lbs

    Prefers Somewhat Softer

    Arthritis, Back Pain (lower / middle), Fibromyalgia, Hip Pain, Sleeping Hot

    0
    Male
    Review left on Feb 13, 2022

    Ratings from this sleeper:

    Back Support
    3/ 5
    Pressure Relief
    3/ 5
    Sleep Quality
    4/ 5
    Stays "Cool"
    3/ 5
    Value
    N/A
    Warranty Service
    N/A
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Owned for: 10 years
    Condition: Very worn

    55 - 64 years old

    Male

    200-250 lbs

    Prefers Medium

    Arthritis, Back Pain (lower / middle), Hip Pain, Back Pain (upper / neck), Osteoporosis, Sleeping Hot

    0
    Male
    JohnPierre, SD
    Review left on Sep 6, 2021

    Ratings from this sleeper:

    Back Support
    4/ 5
    Pressure Relief
    3/ 5
    Sleep Quality
    5/ 5
    Stays "Cool"
    4/ 5
    Value
    N/A
    Warranty Service
    N/A
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Owned for: 1-3 months
    Condition: Slightly worn

    45 - 54 years old

    Male

    Stomach Sleeper

    200-250 lbs

    Prefers Medium

    Arthritis, Back Pain (lower / middle), Back Pain (upper / neck), Scoliosis, Sleep Apnea, Spinal Stenosis, Spondylolisthesis

    0
    Female
    WendyCary, NC
    Review left on Apr 27, 2021

    Ratings from this sleeper:

    Back Support
    4/ 5
    Pressure Relief
    3/ 5
    Sleep Quality
    4/ 5
    Stays "Cool"
    4/ 5
    Value
    N/A
    Warranty Service
    N/A
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Owned for: More than a year
    Condition: Completely worn

    45 - 54 years old

    Female

    Side Sleeper

    150-200 lbs

    Prefers Medium

    Acid Reflux, Airborne Allergies, Arthritis, Back Pain (lower / middle), Hip Pain, Back Pain (upper / neck), Osteoporosis, Scoliosis, Sleeping Hot, Spinal Stenosis, Spondylolisthesis

    0
    Female
    Review left on Feb 22, 2018

    Ratings from this sleeper:

    Back Support
    5/ 5
    Pressure Relief
    5/ 5
    Sleep Quality
    5/ 5
    Stays "Cool"
    4/ 5
    Value
    N/A
    Warranty Service
    N/A
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Owned for: 10 years
    Condition: Moderately worn

    25 - 34 years old

    Female

    Stomach Sleeper

    100-150 lbs

    Prefers Somewhat Softer

    0
    Female
    MChapel Hill, NC
    Review left on Oct 29, 2017

    Ratings from this sleeper:

    Back Support
    4/ 5
    Pressure Relief
    5/ 5
    Sleep Quality
    4/ 5
    Stays "Cool"
    5/ 5
    Value
    N/A
    Warranty Service
    N/A
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Owned for: 10 years
    Condition: Like new

    35 - 44 years old

    Female

    Back Sleeper

    100-150 lbs

    Prefers Somewhat Harder

    Airborne Allergies, Back Pain (lower / middle), Hip Pain

    0
    Female
    Review left on May 2, 2017

    Ratings from this sleeper:

    Back Support
    4/ 5
    Pressure Relief
    3/ 5
    Sleep Quality
    5/ 5
    Stays "Cool"
    5/ 5
    Value
    N/A
    Warranty Service
    N/A
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Owned for: 9 years
    Condition: Very worn

    55 - 64 years old

    Female

    Back Sleeper

    100-150 lbs

    Prefers Medium

    Back Pain (lower / middle), Hip Pain

    0
    Female
    Review left on May 27, 2016

    Ratings from this sleeper:

    Back Support
    4/ 5
    Pressure Relief
    3/ 5
    Sleep Quality
    5/ 5
    Stays "Cool"
    3/ 5
    Value
    N/A
    Warranty Service
    N/A
    This review is for Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop
    Owned for: 8 years
    Condition: Moderately worn

    Over 65 years old

    Female

    < 100 lbs

    Prefers Medium

    Acid Reflux, Airborne Allergies, Arthritis, Back Pain (lower / middle), Hip Pain, Back Pain (upper / neck), Osteoporosis, Scoliosis, Spinal Stenosis

    0
    Sealy Posturepedic Bethany Bay Plush Pillowtop Mattress Reviews | GoodBed