Beautyrest Silver (2017-2019)
Mattress Ratings & Reviews

Beautyrest Silver (2017-2019) logo
76/100
Very Good
Back Support
57
Pressure Relief
60
Sleep Quality
60
Stays "Cool"
65
Value
55
Warranty Service
52
Average Lifespan
N/A
Back Support
57
Pressure Relief
60
Sleep Quality
60
Stays "Cool"
65
Value
55
Warranty Service
52
Average Lifespan
N/A
FILTER
1,042 total ratings, 30 with reviews
Male
allanTappan, NY
Review left on Jun 5, 2023

Started off Great

After 5 years there is no support in the mattress.
This review is for Simmons Beautyrest Silver Waterscape Plush Pillowtop
Owned for: 5 years
Condition: Very worn

Over 65 years old

Male

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

0
See full review

Female
DianeMilford, MI
Review left on May 20, 2022

It’s awful

We feel like it has sunk in the middle terribly. This started after only two years. I hate this mattress so much. I CANNOT believe that we want a new mattress after owning this less than 4 years. I am never comfortable and my shoulders, back and neck hurt every morning.
This review is for Simmons Beautyrest Silver Crystal Ridge Plush Pillowtop
Owned for: 3 years
Condition: Moderately worn

55 - 64 years old

Female

Back Sleeper

100-150 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

0
See full review

Male
donaldAlbuquerque, NM
Review left on Mar 8, 2022

Honestly, an exceptional mattress especially with back pain

I am an engineer so I studied replacing our old Simmons Beautyrest; tried 4 different mattresses including one foam block style. This mattress is the best we have ever owned; it is especially good for someone with lumbar (lower) back pain in my opinion. Replacing old mattress with this oe cut back pain by 75% right away. Also the "materials" offering is no joke , it is a tremendously comfortable sleep, especially noted by my wife, a former dancer. I read the oter review and sounds like a manufacturing problem. Honestky, we went and bought five (5) more of these and put them in our second ski home in Colorado. No problems and only compliments from various users. Again, 5 star for us but just our opinion; we have no affiliation or deal with Beautirest etc. American quality should be appreciated!
This review is for Beautyrest Silver Grays Reef Luxury Firm
Owned for: 3 years
Condition: Like new

Over 65 years old

Male

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

0
See full review

Female
JacquelineMonrovia, CA
Review left on Sep 10, 2021

Mattress caved in

After several months the right end of this mattress sunk. I don’t recommend this mattress, huge disappointment.
This review is for Beautyrest Silver Grays Reef Luxury Firm
Owned for: More than a year

Over 65 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

100-150 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

0
See full review

Female
DianeIndianapolis, IN
Review left on Aug 18, 2021

Indentation/Sagging after 5 nights

After 5 nights of sleeping on this new, not so cheap mattress, there is a butt indentation. Emailed BeautyRest, gave them information (no copy of receipt), and they emailed me back in 2 business days. They asked for tag information (already sent a photo) and a copy of the purchase receipt, then one or two days later told me to contact the store where I purchased it. Store never answered my email (their preference), had to call them and waiting on a 3rd party to come out and look at it.
This review is for Simmons Beautyrest Silver Edgewater Plush Pillowtop
Owned for: Less than a year
Condition: Like new

55 - 64 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Medium Feel

0
See full review

Male
CherylSan Antonio, TX
Review left on Apr 27, 2021

Big lump down the middle

I am very unhappy with my purchase. Mattress has 10year warranty but is totally useless. Middle of the bed is 2" higher, terrible sleep with sunken down on each side. Purchased from Macy's and they are not standing by their product. Even looks bad when the bed is made up. SAD!
This review is for Simmons Beautyrest Silver Waterscape Luxury Firm
Owned for: 3 years
Condition: Very worn

55 - 64 years old

Prefers Medium Feel

0
See full review

Male
MikeLe Mars, IA
Review left on Jan 2, 2021

Terrible Both timex

Had to replace the first one after two years due to sink holes. The replacement did the same. Durability is non existent.
This review is for Simmons Beautyrest Silver Oak Harbor Extra Firm
Owned for: 4 years

55 - 64 years old

Male

Back Sleeper

200-250 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

Back Pain, Hip Pain, Neck Pain, Sleep Apnea, Sleeping Hot

0
See full review

Female
KaitWestbrook, CT
Review left on Jul 31, 2020

Way Too Soft. No Support

I did a lot of research before buying this mattress, and am so very disappointed. It honestly feels like I'm sinking into it. So soft and no support. Wish quality innerspring mattresses were still around. Maybe at a local retailer? Anyway, I do not recommend this mattress for anyone. It can't be good for your body. Hope this helps!
This review is for Simmons Beautyrest Silver Lydia Manor III Plush PillowTop
Owned for: 1 year
Condition: Completely worn

25 - 34 years old

Female

Side Sleeper

150-200 lbs

Prefers Harder Feel

Back Pain, Neck Pain

0
See full review

Female
Dawn
Review left on Jul 15, 2020

horrible body aches

This mattress keep me up not able to get comfortable. Body aches.in the morning. Just horrible. My cats love it. Just bought a new one! This is going into the trash !
This review is for Beautyrest Silver Hybrid (2017-2019)
Owned for: 3 years
Condition: Like new

45 - 54 years old

Female

Stomach Sleeper

150-200 lbs

0
See full review

Female
ChristinaGreen Valley, AZ
Review left on May 5, 2020

As Time Goes By, Progressively Worse!

I'm a 200# stomach sleeper. I've now slept on this mattress for 13 months, and would much rather have my 10-year-used conventional mattress back! For the first month break-in period, it felt like sleeping on a sack of wet sand. Now there is a groove which I can hardly roll away from. The mattress edge, however, surprisingly does well. I'm waking up with aches and pains. I hate this mattress! Definitely not what I expected. Would not recommend.
This review is for Simmons Beautyrest Silver Lydia Manor III Luxury Firm
Owned for: 1 year
Condition: Very worn

Over 65 years old

Female

Stomach Sleeper

200-250 lbs

Prefers Softer Feel

Plus Size, Sleeping Hot

0
See full review+ 1 comment